
Vol. 3, Issue 2 (2014)
Science & Cycling Congress, 2/3 July 2014, Leeds
August 2014
Pages 1–85
Book of Abstracts of the Science & Cycling Congress
Book of Abstracts
-
Power output and affective load change during time trial according to environmental conditions
Introduction: During cycling events, riders have to face to different environmental conditions like wind or road gradient, which leads to variable resistive forces. Those resistances involve a specific pedaling cadence (PC) – crank inertial load (CIL) association and modify the level of power output (PO) (Hansen et al., 2002). The different environmental conditions also could influence the affective load (AL), defined like the difference between perception of exertion rate and pleasure (Baron et al., 2011). The purpose of this study was to analyze the influence of different environmental conditions on PO and AL.
Method: Eight amateur competitive cyclists performed five 25 ± 5min TT sessions at their maximal capacity in different environmental conditions: 1) in level ground with 3 different wind conditions: no wind (NW), headwind (HW), tailwind (TW). The wind velocity was 40 ± 5 km/h, 2) in uphill (UP) with a mean slope of 8% and 3) on Home Trainer (HT). PO was recorded from a Power Tap® power meter. Every 4 minutes, riders had to rate their exercise perceived exertion from a CR10 Borg scale and their pleasure on a “pleasure scale” to evaluate their AL. An ANOVA statistical test was used to analyze the evolution of PO and AL over the time between the different conditions.
Results: PO is significantly different between all conditions and varies over the time. Different pacing strategies are observed with a fast start and a final spurt. PO is higher in NW and TW (+ 3.5%) compared with HW and UP. There are correlations between PC and cycling speed (v) (r = 0.84, p<0.001) and between CIL and v (r = 0.92, p<0.001). AL increases over the time (p<0.05) for all the conditions and is significantly different between all conditions (p<0.05). AL is higher (+56%) in HW compared with the others conditions.
Discussion / Conclusion: PO varies significantly according to wind and road gradient conditions. For each condition, riders select a specific PC – CIL combination which modifies PO and AL. The higher AL observed in HW was not associated with the higher PO. The changes in the PC – CIL combinations determined different whole body sensations that could play a role on AL. The changes in resistive forces involve different crank torque profiles which modify the force-length relationship, the muscular contraction velocity and muscular strains. So, to decrease AL it seems necessary to adopt an optimal gear according to the field and learn to tame the environmental conditions. This requires specific and regular training. -
The effect of exercise mode on salivary IgA secretion in high level triathletes
Background: It is widely accepted that exercise of either long duration or high intensity can have suppressive effects on the immune system. However, it remains to be identified if exercise mode plays a part in the deterioration of immune function.
Purpose: The objective of this study was to determine if exercise mode played a part in the acute immune responses to exercise.
Methods: Eight male high-level triathletes [Age mean 32.8, s = 2.4, VO2max ml.kg.minˉٰ mean 72.6, s = 2.4] performed a 2-hour bout of exercise at 55% of their peak power output (watts) [mean 192.5, s = 4.5] on both a treadmill and cycle ergometer, each separated by seven days. Saliva samples were obtained both pre and post both protocols. Saliva flow rate was calculated from the volume of saliva and time taken to produce the sample. sIgA concentration was measured by indirect enzyme linked immunosorbent assay, from which sIgA secretion rate was calculated.
Results: sIgA concentrations (µg.mlˉٰ) before and after the treadmill were [mean 595, s = 64.6 and mean 841, s = 76.3] and before and after the bike were [mean 593.9, s = 51.1 and 778.8 s = 99.3]. sIgA secretion rates (µg.minˉٰ) before and after the treadmill were [mean 396.2, s = 73.7 and 223 s = 99.6] and before and after the bike were [mean 284.1, s = 74.3 and 216.6, s = 29.5]. Saliva flow rates (µl.minˉٰ) before and after the treadmill were [mean 657.8, s = 92.2 and 289.3, s = 56.6] and before and after the bike were [mean 487.2, s = 123.3 and 319.5, s = 66.5]. The results indicated that sIgA secretion rate (P < 0.028) and saliva flow rate (P < 0.01) were significantly decreased following the 2 hour treadmill protocol but not the 2 hour bike protocol. sIgA concentration was also significantly elevated following the treadmill (P < 0.01), with no significant increase following the bike protocol.
Discussion: Previous studies have shown that with a decrease in sIgA secretion rate and saliva flow rate there is subsequently going to be an increase in URTI episodes in the individual. This increase in URTIs can hamper an athlete’s preparation for competition resulting in sub-par performance, which may result in loss of sponsorship deals or contracts. Conclusions: The results suggest that long duration running may be more detrimental to immune function than long duration cycling in triathletes. -
Influence of positional biomechanics on gross efficiency within cycling
Background: Research has found that manipulation of a single variable of bike-fit such as saddle height can improve performance within cycling efficiency (Peveler, & Green., 2010: Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 25(3), 1–5) and reduce aerodynamic drag (Garcia-Lopez et al., 2008: Journal of Sports Science, 26, 277-286). However, limited research exists concerning the biomechanical influences on gross efficiency, a key factor in endurance performance (Ettema, & Lorås., 2009: European journal of applied physiology, 106(1)1–14). In addition, many private companies offer numerous bike-fitting systems yet fail to provide consistent findings. The present study proposed to build on previous research by using a dynamic bike fitting system to explore how a number of biomechanical manipulations to a cyclist’s position can affect performance and cycling gross efficiency.
Purpose: The main aim of the study was to investigate the effects on performance by manipulating a cyclist’s bike fit in-line with normative bike fitting data. For the purpose of this study the identifiable performance improvement was gross efficiency (GE) and the system that was used to perform the bike-fit was the Retül bike-fit system. The hypothesis tested was that changing a well-trained cyclist’s position in-line with normative data using a popular bike fitting system could improve performance in cycling gross efficiency.
Method: Six well-trained cyclists (mean ±s: age, 30 ±13.1 years; height, 179.9 ±5.7 cm; mass, 75.1 ±8.1 kg; Wmax, 330 ±19.1 W; VO2 max, 66.1 ±10.3 mL.kg-1.min-1) completed one VO2max test, two sub maximal tests and one Retül bike fit. Submaximal tests consisted of three randomised 8 min incremental workloads of 50%, 60% and 70% VO2max. VO2 and VCO2 were recorded for final 4 min. The tests measured maximal minute power (Wmax), blood lactate, VO2max, VO2, VCO2 and GE. The data was analyzed using a Wilcoxon signed-rank test and a one tailed t-test.
Results: Significant changes were observed (p=0.037) during the post bike-fit condition within the 60% Wmax increment (16.78% vs.17.44%; p= .037). Although non-significant, increases were apparent within the 50% Wmax increment (16.27% vs. 16.44%; p= 0.565) and again within the 70% Wmax workload (17.60% vs. 18.18%; p= 0.111).
Discussion: The findings of the present study show higher % increases in GE than previous studies related to changes in GE over time (2.74% in the present study vs. 1-2% (Coyle, 1995: Exerc. Sport Sci. Rev. 23, 25–63). This suggests biomechanical changes can improve performance in well-trained cyclists. Further analysis shows a possible trend within cycling experience and GE improvements within the participant group that would benefit from further investigation.
Conclusion: This study has found an increase in gross efficiency between pre and post bike-fit conditions. Specifically, one of the more noteworthy findings to emerge from this study is that at 60% Wmax GE was significantly increased across the participant group. Although the current study is based on a small sample of participants, the findings suggest that overall the absolute % increase in GE within each incremental workload would offer performance enhancements following improvements to their bike position. -
Laboratory predictors of uphill cycling time trial performance
Background: A field test which can be easily integrated into the training routine of cyclists to monitor performance changes is valuable. It has been demonstrated that when performing a 20-min outdoor time trial (TT), cyclists produce approximately 5.4% higher mean power output during uphill than flat routes (Nimmerichter et al., 2012: European Journal of Applied Physiology, 112(1), 69-78). Therefore, this discrepancy raises questions the relationship between uphill TT performance and physiological parameters obtained during laboratory graded exercise tests (GXT), as previously demonstrated on flat courses.
Methods: Separated by at least 48 hours, eleven male and one female moderately trained cyclists (30±5 years; 78.7±16.2 kg; 175±8 cm; mean±s) undertook a 30-s Wingate test on a mechanically braked cycle ergometer (Biotec2100, Cefise, Nova Odessa, Brazil) fitted with a power-measuring crank (SRM, Jülich, Germany), a GXT to exhaustion (Computrainer ProLab, RacerMate, Seattle, USA) and a 20-min outdoor uphill TT (2.8% mean gradient). GXT pulmonary gas exchanges were measured using breath-by-breath analyses (K4b2, Cosmed, Rome, Italy). During the TT, power output was measured using a mobile power-meter (PowerTap, Saris, Madison, USA).
Results: Multiple linear regressions demonstrated that 95% of the variation in TT mean power output (PTT) was predicted by GXT VO2max and the respiratory compensation point (RCP), with standardized beta coefficients of 0.68 and 0.37 respectively. Moderate intraclass correlation coefficients were demonstrated for 94.6% PTT and RCP power (r = 0.87; 95%CI: 0.47-0.96). Bland Altman plot showed a bias ± random error of 4.4±51.6 W or 1.2±21.1 %. Mean values for Wingate 5-s peak power, Wingate 30-s mean power, PTT and 94.6% PTT were 899±163 W; 668±108 W; 295±53 W and 279±50 W, respectively. Mean values for GXT peak power output (Pmax), VO2max, RCP power and VT power were 341±46 W; 4.44±0.73 L.min-1; 274±45 W and 173±31 W, respectively.
Discussion: The results of this study demonstrate that 95% uphill PTT can be explained by physiological laboratory parameters of VO2max and RCP. Moreover, when PTT is adjusted according to the findings of Nimmerichter et al. (2012), RCP power output agrees better with it. Consequently, this finding adds more experimental evidence for the predictive validity of the 20-min outdoor TT to estimate power output at RCP during GXT, provided that the uphill course is taken to account and a 5.4% subtraction is made to PTT.
Conclusion: A 20-min outdoor TT performed on an uphill course can be utilized to predict with reasonable accuracy, power output at the respiratory compensation point and to monitor performance changes on moderately trained cyclists. -
Gross efficiency is improved in standing position with an increase of the power output
Background: Gross efficiency (GE) has been shown to be one of the most relevant parameter influencing cycling performance but to the best of our knowledge, just one study focused on measuring GE in seated and standing positions during field conditions (Millet et al., 2002: Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 34(10), 1645-52). Other authors investigated the effects of change in body position (seated vs. standing) on energy expenditure, heart rate (HR) or pulmonary ventilation (VE) but there were large changes in the results (Ryschon & Stray-Gundersen, 1991: Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 23, 949-953; Swain & Wilcox, 1992: Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 24, 1123-1127) due to the different protocols. Indeed, the cross effect of slope and intensity on GE in standing compared to seated position has not been studied. Thus, we found interesting to measure GE in real locomotion with elite cyclists at different intensities and slopes.
Purpose: This study was designed to examine the effects of standing position on GE compared to seated position at different intensities and slopes.
Methods: After a period of familiarisation, 13 elite participants performed on a motorised treadmill with their own bike one session during which they rode in a randomized order seated vs. standing positions with several slopes (5, 7.5 and 10%) and intensities (3.8, 4.2 and 4.6 W.kg-1). GE was calculated for each condition using the ratio of power output (PO) measured with a Powertap G3 hub (CycleOps, Madison, USA) and the oxygen uptake (VO2) measured with a portable gas analyzer (Metamax 3B, Cortex, Leipzig, Germany).
Results: GE was significantly higher (+4.5%) in standing position (21.5 ± 5.2 %, CV = 5.2%) compared to seated position (20.6 ± 1.1 %, CV = 5.5%) for all the intensities and slopes. This improvement was due to a significant (p < 0.001) increase of PO in standing position (+4.5%) associated with a stabilization of VO2. The more the slope was low and the intensity was high, the more the pedaling cadence was high. That leads to higher PO changes between standing and seated positions (R = 0.93, p < 0.001) (Figure 1).
Discussion: The main finding of this study shows that in standing position, GE was increased from a higher PO. The non-significant increase in VO2 is in accordance with the previous results of Millet et al. (2002). It's the first time that a study shows an increase in PO in standing position. The difference in PO is linked to an increase of the pedaling cadence. We hypothesize that the increase in PO is due to the technique adopted in standing position, the latter has an impact on the mechanical deformation both of the tires and the bike frame. The loss of energy in the bike and the tires would require to increase the PO in standing position according to the technique of each cyclist.
Conclusion: Despite a significant decrease of GE, the standing position involves a significant increase in PO probably due to an increase of the deformation of both the tires and the bike frame according to the pedaling techniques of the cyclist. -
Relationship between leg length and trunk orientation in cycling
Background: Rider position for a time trial will depend on several variables, including aerodynamics and sporting regulations set by the international governing body of cycling, the Union Cycliste Internationale (UCI). At 50kph, aerodynamic drag accounts for 90% of the resistance experienced by a rider (Grappe et al., 1997: Ergonomics, 40, 1299–1311). Between 60-70% of aerodynamic resistance is accounted for by the cyclist’s position (Kyle and Burke, 1984: Mechanical Engineering, 106(9), 34-45.). Reducing a rider's trunk orientation makes them more aerodynamic and therefore able to go faster for the same effort (Defraeye et al., 2010: Journal of Biomechanics, 43(7), 1262-8 ).
Purpose: A better understanding of segment orientation during time trials may also allow for further optimisation and improvements in sporting performance.This study investigated segment orientation across a range of different leg lengths (LL), focusing on minimum trunk orientation when hip flexion at the top of the pedal stroke is limited to 140 degrees. This study was designed to assess the hypothesis that trunk orientation is negatively correlated with LL and as such there may be a performance advantage as LL increases.
Methods: Fifteen recreationally-active and competitive male cyclists (age 37.2 ± 4.8 years, height 1.77 ± 0.06 m) were recruited from local cycling and triathlon clubs.A cross-sectional experimental design was employed consisting of one independent variable, LL, and one dependent variable, trunk orientation. An adjustable fitting jig was set for each participant to optimize a UCI-legal time trial position with saddle set-back fixed at 5cm to comply with UCI regulation 1.3.013. The following variables were also set within industry standard ranges: sagittal plane joint rotations at the knee, hip and shoulder.
Results: Trunk orientation was measured as an indicator of aerodynamic performance. Its correlation with LL was moderate and negative, r(13) = -0.61, p = 0.015, which shows that as LL increases, trunk orientation decreases. Correlation between LL and trunk orientation was significant at the 0.05 level, with a mean of 11.5 degrees and standard deviation of 3 degrees.
Discussion: Trunk orientation was found to have a moderate negative correlation with LL. This implies that riders with a longer LL gain a performance advantage through being able to rotate further forwards in a sagittal plane, which previous studies have shown helps riders become more aerodynamic and therefore achieve higher speeds for the same effort (Defraeye et al., 2010: Journal of Biomechanics, 43(7), 1262-8).Crank length is a variable that could explain this correlation. As crank length was fixed, proportional crank length varied from a minimum of 18.9% to a maximum of 21.9% of LL. This study could have significant implications for sporting regulations, bicycle design and racing time trial positions. -
The analysis & forecasting of British cycling time trial records
Background: The sport of cycling time trials in Great Britain has taken place over several distance or time based formats since 1935. The format of this sport typically involves riders competing individually over several fixed race distances of 10-100 miles in length or using time constrained formats of 12 and 24 hours in duration. The aim of the sport is to cover the fixed race distance or duration at the highest possible speed. Each of these events has its own national record. A new record can be established and ratified at any point of the year when achieved in an event of the same race length.
Purpose: An evaluation of British cycling time trials over a maximum period of 80 years may provide some insight into the progression of the sports records and what performances may be possible by athletes in the future.
Methods: The progression of time trial records across six events were plotted and reviewed. This data was obtained from the sport’s governing body website and annual handbook. The fixed distances that were investigated were the 10, 25, 50 and 100 mile distances. In addition, the 12 hour and 24 hour fixed duration events were also analysed. To determine forecasts for each records future progression, the ‘Singular Spectrum Analysis’ (SSA) technique was applied to the historical record data. This time series analysis technique has not been applied to sports-based data to date.
Results: The data from all 6 events typically follows a non-linear progression of performance. Excluding the relatively recent introduction of the 10 mile distance, the five other datasets all saw a high frequency of new records being established from 1950-1969 and a reduction in the frequency after this. Conversely, since 1970 these records have indicated a larger percentage improvement when they have occurred. The SSA technique provided forecasts using a line of best fit with a minimum of 99% goodness of fit for all six datasets. The SSA forecasts projected that by 2030, the records would stand as 16:51 (10 miles), 41:48 (25 miles), 1:27:40 (50 miles), 3:03:57 (100 miles), 323.76 miles (12 hour) and 550.937 miles (24 hour).
Discussion: The non-linear nature of the records is typical of the characteristics recorded in other endurance sports over long term time periods. However, to achieve the SSA forecasts, these would then require substantial improvements in a riders physiological power output and/or reductions in their aerodynamic drag. However, cycling time trials have historically also been subjected to the influence of sociological factors such as traffic flow, weather and favorable course design. As a result, such targets may well be assisted by the impact or development of positive factors outside of the rider’s control. Further research into the impact of traffic drafting and course topographies may well provide further evidence to reinforce the projections successfully modeled here.
Conclusion: A review of six British cycling time trial records generally demonstrated a decreasing frequency of attainment but larger margins of improvement over time. Further improvements in performance were forecasted with a high percentage of line fit using the Singular Spectrum Analysis technique. These forecasts provide challenging targets and would require a combination of favorable improvements in physiological power generation, reductions in total aerodynamic drag and other conditions outside of the riders’ direct control. -
The effect of IMT on cycling time-trial performance at ~16°C (cool) and ~26°C (hot) temperatures
Objective: The purpose of this study was to investigate whether inspiratory muscle training (IMT) improved cycling time-trial (CTT) performance in both cool (~16°C) and hot (~26°C) environmental conditions in well-trained competitive male cyclists.
Method: Twelve males were recruited (age: 39.3 ± 12.1 yrs.). Eight participants were assigned to the experimental (IMT) group (VO2max: 63.4 ± 7.6 ml • min-1 • kg-1; age: 41.4 ± 8.5 yrs.) and 4 to the control (CTRL) group (VO2max: 62.1 ±13.6 ml • min-1 • kg-1; age: 35.0 ± 18.1 yrs.). The IMT groups were prescribed an IMT training intervention and performance was assessed using a 10-km CTT in cool and hot conditions, pre- and post-intervention. IMT was performed using a pressure threshold loading (PTL) device set at 50% maximal inspiratory pressure (PImax) twice daily for 6-weeks.
Results: CTT performance improved in the IMT group in the cool but not the hot. The IMT group went 1.17% faster in the cool (pre- vs. post-intervention: 940.38 ± 91.00 s vs. 929.38 ± 81.75 s) and 0.69% slower in the hot (927.63 ± 79.65 vs. 934.00 ± 74.73 s) (P>0.05). Post-intervention PImax increased in the IMT group both pre- and post-CTT by 25.90% and 22.01%; and 32.54% and 33.63%; respectively in the cool (P<0.05) and hot (P<0.05); the CTRL group observed no significant change.
Discussion and Conclusions: IMT increased inspiratory muscle strength (IMS), attenuated inspiratory muscle fatigue (IMF) and improved CTT performance in the cool but not the hot condition. Heart rate increase (HRinc) was attenuated during the hot CTT and an increase in ear temperature (Tear) was counteracted during the cool CTT for a concurrent increase in physiological workload. In conclusion, IMT is a proven ergogenic aid for well-trained cyclists confirming that elite cyclists can still benefit from marginal gains. -
Individualised training duration induces similar physiological and performance benefits at different intensities
Background: When comparing the effects of different training intensities, studies often standardise for energy expenditure. These studies tend to suggest that high intensity training (HIT) provides greater or similar benefits as moderate intensity training (MOD). However, the time (and energy expenditure) that an individual can sustain at the same relative intensity is highly variable. The possible impact of this variability on response to training has been largely ignored.
Purpose: The aim of this study was to compare the effects of three different exercise intensities; HIT, MOD and a combination of the two (MIX) when the training duration is individualised.
Methods: Participants were sedentary and recreationally active males and females training < 4h/wk. Thirty-four participants (mean ± SD; age 28 ± 9yr, mass 75.8 ± 12kg) were randomly assigned to the MOD (n=11; VO2max = 3.37 ± 0.79 l.min-1); HIT (n=12; VO2max = 3.12 ± 0.58 l.min-1) and MIX (n=11; VO2max = 3.75 ± 0.67 l.min-1) training groups. Before and after 4-wks of supervised training (4 times/wk) we measured VO2max and maximal minute power, time-to-exhaustion at 60% of maximal minute power, and cycling efficiency. The MOD group trained at 60% of maximal minute power in blocks of 5-min and 1-min passive recovery. The training duration was individualised to 100% of their pre-training time-to-exhaustion test. The HIT group trained at 100% maximal minute power for 2-min repetitions with 3-min recovery. The duration was set as the maximum number of repetitions completed in the first session and this was used as a baseline for subsequent sessions. The MIX group completed two MOD and two HIT sessions each week. All participants were encouraged to complete an extra block or repetition after every two training sessions. The effects of training were analysed using a two-way mixed ANOVA (time; training group). The level of significance was set at P<0.05. Effect size for each statistical test was also calculated as partial eta squared (ηp2).
Results: Average total time spent exercising for the HIT, MOD and MIX groups was ~ 6h, 16h and 10.5h respectively. All three training groups significantly increased their VO2max, maximal minute power and time-to-exhaustion following 4-weeks of training (P<0.05). However, there were no significant differences between groups for VO2max (P=0.378, ηp2=0.06); maximal minute power (P=0.634, ηp2=0.03) and time-to-exhaustion (P=0.582, ηp2=0.03) (P<0.05). There was an interaction effect for cycling efficiency (P=0.02, ηp2=0.22). A follow up test revealed no difference between groups at baseline (all P>0.590) and a significant increase in cycling efficiency for the MIX group only (P=0.009). Inter-individual differences in training responses were high for all variables.
Discussion: When training durations are tailored to each individual, similar improvements are found in VO2max, maximal minute power and time-to-exhaustion, despite a substantially greater time spent training at MOD intensity. A significantly greater increase in cycling efficiency following MIX training warrants further investigation, with research suggesting that training based on a polarised distribution might be more beneficial, avoiding training monotony (Neal et al., 2013: Journal of Applied Physiology, 144 (4) 461-471).
Conclusion: These findings support the contention that individualised HIT and MIX are time-efficient training strategies inducing similar changes when compared to MOD. -
Differences in static and dynamic bike fit with 3d motion capture
Background: Bicycle fitting is the adjustment of bicycle configuration to suit rider requirements through appropriate placement of contact points; pedals, saddle and handlebars (Burke 1994: Clin Sports Med, 13(1), 1-14). Traditional fitting uses static assessment of parameters such as knee angle through the bottom of the pedal stroke and saddle setback measured by knee over pedal horizontal separation (KOPS) (Holmes et al., 1994: Clinics in Sports Medicine 13(1), 187). Dynamic fitting is now increasingly popular through video analysis or 3d motion capture. However no comparison has been made of differences between static and dynamic measurement or assessment reported of the reliability of motion capture for bicycle fitting.
Purpose: To investigate the repeatability of key bike fitting kinematic parameters and differences between static and dynamic conditions.
Methods: 15 subjects performed repeated motion capture trials over three sessions in both static and dynamic conditions. Markers were applied to anatomical landmarks and kinematics collected using a Vicon 3d motion capture system.
Results: Typical intra-session errors for angular parameters ranged from 1.7° (4.2°) for dynamic (static) knee flexion to 4.2° (4.9°) for ankle plantarflexion. Typical error for KOPS was 6.6 mm (12 mm). Significant (p<0.001) differences between static and dynamic conditions were observed for all parameters. Knee flexion was 5.4° greater in dynamic conditions (95% CI 3.5°, 7.4°). Corresponding dynamic ankle plantarflexion was 7.8° greater (5.9°, 9.6°) and hip flexion 5.1° greater (3.8°, 6.5°). KOPS was 7.7 mm further forward in dynamic conditions (3.3, 12.1) and dynamic ankle plantarflexion at KOPS was 3.6° greater (1.8°, 5.4°).
Discussion: Typical errors showed moderate repeatability indicating the system was fit for purpose but these errors require consideration in the fitting process. Differences between static and dynamic parameters appear to originate at the ankle, with a tendency for riders to drop their heels when stationary.
Conclusion: Common guidance to fit to a knee angle between 25-35° should be adjusted to 30-40° for dynamic measurement. -
Optimal pacing strategy for a race of two competing cyclists
Background: For optimal pacing strategies in the case of two or more competing or cooperating cyclists only few approaches take slipstreaming into account. However, by incorporating the slipstream effect in the model of a race of two runners on a flat course, it has been shown, how the trailing runner can position himself at striking distance behind the other and when he should start the final sprint. (Pitcher, 2009: Optimal strategies for a two-runner model of middle-distance running. SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics, 70(4), 1032–1046).
Purpose: We transfer this approach to cycling on a track of fixed length with real-world height data. In particular on descents, high speed is involved and increases the significance of the slipstreaming strategy.
Methods: We adopt the standard mechanical bicycling model that accounts for pedaling power, gravity, friction, inertia, and aerial drag. The nominal aerial drag force is multiplied by a slipstream factor that has its minimum when the cyclist is located closely behind his opponent (Pitcher, 2009). Our physiological model defines the remaining anaerobic capacity that de-/increases non-linearly when the pedaling power exceeds/falls below critical power (Gordon, 2005: Optimizing distribution of power during a cycling time trial. Sports Engineering, 8(2), 81–90). The mechanical and physical parameters may be different for the two cyclists. We use a state-of-the-art optimal control method for the numerical computations (Patterson et al., 2013: GPOPS-II: A MATLAB software for solving multiple-phase optimal control problems using hp-adaptive gaussian quadrature collocation methods and sparse nonlinear programming. ACM Transactions on Mathematical Software, 39(3).).
Results: The optimal pacing strategy for two cyclists on a competition between Saint-Gildas-des-Bois to Redon (stage 3 of the Tour de France 2013), France, is shown in Figure 1.
Discussion and Conclusion: Slipstreaming has a significant impact on pacing strategies in cycling. Incorporated into the mechanical bicycling model, optimal control algorithms can be used to compute the optimal tactic for the final sprint. Future work should take into account that the cyclists will often cooperate to stay ahead of the peloton before they compete in the final sprint phase. -
Past attempts to identify a single physiological parameter as the main indicator of success in the tour de France seem to have failed
Background: Past attempts to identify a single physiological parameter as the main indicator of success in the tour de France seem to have failed.
Purpose: To evaluate the validity of the critical power model for the analysis of exhaustive power-time curves of grand tour winners.
Methods: The climbing time and the corresponding average climbing power for final and non-final climbs in the tour de France, The Giro and the Vuelta are obtained. From the final climbs exhaustive (P-t) relations are constructed and analyzed with the Monod-Scherrer critical power model. For each rider we obtained his critical power CP and his anaerobic work capacity AEC. Results and Discussion: We found vast individual variations in CP and AEC. Neither of these single parameters, nor the pairs could identify the necessary quality for success. Winning CP was between minimum 4.82 W/kg (Hesjedal in 2011) and maximum 5.81 W/kg (Indurain in 1994-95). Winning AEC was between minimum 0.75 kJ/kg (Indurain in 1994-95) and 1.81 kJ/kg (Contador in 2009). Figure 1 shows the variation in CP and AEC, where the values obtained by Froome in 2012-13 were taken as reference values. Although in 2013 Froome and Contador had almost identical aerobic power, Contador fell short in AEC. This was quite different in his winning Tour 2009, when Contador had superior values both for CP and AEC. The highest historical CP-value is probably for Indurain in 1994, although he combined this with the lowest AEC-value. Hesjedal achieved sub-Froome parameters although he had an almost identical ratio of aerobic to anaerobic components. We see also that Horner’s performance in his Vuelta 2013 is almost identical to Indurain in 1994. Also remarkable is the fact (not shown in fig 1) that the average climbing power of Froome in 14 non-exhaustive climbs of (5.05 ± 0.34) is barely lower than his CP of (5.16 ± 0.02) W/kg. This clearly indicates that modern strategy of the dominant teams is the one of “least controlling power” i.e. riding at a pace just below the leaders CP in order to bring him fresh to the foot of the final climb, but at a pace high enough to exhaust the other contenders.
Conclusion: Within the climbing time interval 15 – 60 minutes the Monod-Scherrer critical power model adequately describes the exhausting climbing performances of grand tour champions.In modern cycling the anaerobic component is more important than generally accepted and the practice of estimating the functional threshold power and critical power with a single maximal test over 20 minutes could be invalid. The maximal oxygen uptake for all considered winners is below 90 ml/(min.kg) , with the exception of Indurain in the uncontrolled EPO-years 1994-1995. More investigation of the 2-parameter CP model of the grand tours is necessary and might lead to a performance passport as a supplement to the existing biological passport. Future studies could be facilitated and could gain in public acceptance and credibility with the creation of a public database containing the power data files (SRM, Powertap and others) of all top riders. -
Measures of training stress in cyclists do not usefully predict maximum mean power in competitions
Background: Many competitive cyclists use mobile ergometers to monitor power output during training and competition rides. A training-impulse model is then often used to combine a training-stress score from each ride into measures of "fitness" and "fatigue", the difference in which is interpreted as a measure of "freshness" that might predict competitive performance.
Purpose: To determine the effect of fitness, fatigue and freshness the day before cycling competitions on physiological indicators of performance in the competitions.
Methods: Twenty male and four female competitive cyclists (29 ± 9 y, 71 ± 7 kg, mean ± SD) provided recordings of their SRM or Quarq mobile ergometers for training rides, 55 time trials (16-40 km), and 447 mass-start road races over a 6- to 8-month period. TrainingPeaks software (version WKO+ 3) was used to synthesize fitness, fatigue and freshness scores on the day before each competition and to extract maximal mean power (MMP) for four durations (5 s, 60 s, 5 min, 20 min) from the competition ride. The within-cyclist relationship between each measure of training and each measure of performance was investigated by producing scatterplots of the deviations from each rider's mean training and mean performance measure for time trials and road races in single-day and multi-day competitions. Mixed modeling was used to quantify the relationship as the linear effect of a change of two within-cyclist standard deviations of the measure of training, assuming a smallest important change in performance of 1%.
Results:Individual typical variation in maximum mean power from competition to competition ranged from ±7.1% (5-min MMP) to ±14% (5-s MMP). Scatterplots were generally consistent with a random relationship between the indicators of performance in competitions and the measures of training the previous day, and all effects of training measures on performance measures were unclear.
Discussion: The uncertainty in the relationships between the measures of training and the measures of performance is due to the extremely poor reliability of the measures of maximum mean power. Contextual information about each competition ride might improve the reliability by helping to filter out or otherwise account for poorer performances. Alternatively other measures of performance from competitions are needed to determine whether fitness, fatigue and freshness usefully predict competition performance.
Conclusions: Maximum mean power in competitions is too unreliable to determine whether the measures of fitness, fatigue and freshness provided by mobile ergometers and TrainingPeaks software reflect readiness for competitions. -
Acute effects of small changes in crank length on gross efficiency and pedalling technique during submaximal cycling
Background: To the best of our knowledge, only four experimental studies analysed the influence of the crank length in the efficiency of energy consumption. No significant differences were found on metabolic cost while pedalling with crank lengths between 145 and 200 mm. None of these studies took into account changes in pedalling technique (kinetic and kinematic profile), which might affect both the efficiency of energy consumption and the muscular activity profile of the lower limb (Astrand, 1953: Arbeitsphysiologie, 15, 23-32; Klimt & Voigt, 1974: European Journal of Applied Physiology, 33, 315-326; Morris & Londeree, 1997: Canadian Journal of Applied Physiology, 22, 429-438; McDaniel et al, 2002: Journal of Applied Physiology, 93, 823-828).
Purpose: The main purpose of this study was to assess the acute effects of small changes in crank length assumable by competitive cyclists (±5 mm) on metabolic cost and pedalling technique during submaximal cycling.Methods: Twelve well-trained road cyclists with a minimum of two years competing in cycling and training more than 3000 km participated in the study. They performed in a randomized order three sets of submaximal pedalling (150, 200 & 250W) at a constant cadence (90 rpm) using three commonly used crank lengths (preferred, +5 mm and -5 mm). Simultaneous physiological (oxygen uptake, respiratory exchange ratio, heart rate and gross efficiency) and biomechanical analyses of pedalling were performed (sagittal hip, knee and ankle angles obtained by 2D high-speed video; and torque exerted on the left and right cranks independently every 2º of a complete revolution). Two-way ANOVA with repeated measures was used to analyse the effect of the crank length and power output on biomechanical and physiological variables.
Results: Non-significant effects of crank length on oxygen uptake, RER, heart rate and gross efficiency were found (p>0.05). There was a significant effect (p<0.001) of the crank length on maximum torque (longest cranks increased it between 1.0-2.3 N•m), minimum torque (longest cranks increased it between 1.0-2.2 N•m) and MFE (longest cranks decreased it between 1 0.9-1.9%). Longest cranks also increased (p<0.05) the flexion and range of motion of the hip (0.9-2.5°) and the knee (1.3-3.4°), whereas ankle joint was not affected. No significant effect crank length pedalling power output was found.
Discussion: The main outcome of this study was that small changes in crank length at submaximal intensity and at constant cadence did not produce significant changes on the efficiency of energy consumption whereas significant changes on biomechanical variables (kinetics and kinematics) were produced. A longer crank decreased the MFE due to a greater minimum torque during the upstroke. Moreover, the flexion and the range of motion of the hip and the knee increased while ankle joint was not affected.
Conclusions: In conclusion, kinematic and kinetic changes due to a longer crank were not significant enough to alter the efficiency of energy consumption, although future studies should investigate their long term effects on muscle coordinative pattern in distance events and on overuse injuries. -
Quantification of vibrations during mountain biking
Background: During cross-country mountain biking, riders are subjected to vibrations due to the terrain, which must be damped before reaching the central nervous system. Damping vibrations requires work, which may help to explain the decrease in economy for mountain biking as compared to road cycling (Titlestad et al., 2006 Journal of Sports Sciences, 24(2), 125-135). Purpose: To describe the relationship between vibration mechanics and their interaction with terrain, bicycle and rider during a race pace effort on a cross country mountain bike track.
Methods: Participants (n=8) completed two separate laps on a cross country track using 26” and 29” wheels, at race speed. Power, cadence, speed, heart rate, and geographical position were sampled and logged every second for control purposes. Tri-axial accelerometers located at handlebar centre, lower left arm, lower left leg, seat post, lower back and medial forehead, recorded accelerations with a output rate 128 Hz to measure vibrations experienced during the whole lap and over terrain sections (uphill and downhill). Vibrations were quantified using a root mean square (RMS) and using Fourier analyses.
Results: RMS data showed greater total accelerations for 29” vs 26” wheels (p=0.0020), and a significant interaction of terrain and accelerometer location (p<.0001). While climbing, accelerations were generally low and concentrated at low movement frequencies. While descending, however, high RMS values were seen on the bicycle (handlebar and seat post) and the parts of the body near the interface with the bicycle (left arm and left leg), while lower accelerations at the lower back and head were not significantly different than the accelerations during climbing. In addition, Fourier analyses showed that the accelerations occurred at a higher frequency when compared to uphill sections. No differences between overall power output (p=0.3062) and heart rate (p=0.8423), yet overall time was greater for 26” compared to 29” wheels (p=0.0061). Discussion: The results show that mountain bikers are subjected to large accelerations, or vibrations, particularly during downhill sections. These vibrations are damped before reaching the lower back and head, which requires metabolic work. In addition, 29 inch wheels showed a clear performance advantage, going faster for the same average power, although resulting in greater vibrations for the riders.
Conclusion: This study demonstrates an additional non-propulsive, muscular challenge to riding during cross country mountain biking represented by a change in accelerations at the point of interface between bike-body compared to lower back and head. -
A new test battery to assess bike handling skills of experienced and inexperienced cyclists
Background: Bike handling skills aimed to maintain balance are important to prevent falling off the bike and/or crashing into obstacles. Past research on dynamics and control of bicycles is inconclusive on how human balance during cycling and how they control trajectories and direction during cycling (Moore et al., 2011, Proceedings of the ASME 2009 International Design and Engineering Technical Conferences & Computers and Information in Engineering Conference, 1-20). Purpose: Our aim was to develop a valid and reliable test to discriminate between good and poor bike handling skills. Additionally, we were interested how the motor control mechanisms during cycling differ between expert and novice cyclists. We hypothesised that 1) cycling deviation amplitude will reliably show differences between novices and experts and 2) experts will perform smoother and smaller steering corrections compared to the novices.
Methods: 14 experienced cyclists (riding over 2000 km per year) 14 inexperienced cyclists (riding a bike less than 100 km per year) volunteered to ride a commuting bike in the lab for 7 metres under three different conditions: in the centre of the lane with flying and standing start, and following a line with a flying start. We measured deviation from the centre of the lane or line, steering and leaning (Vicon system). Two-way mixed ANOVA (condition (3) x group (2)) was applied to test for differences between the groups. Inter-session reliability was assessed with reliability test using Cronbach alpha.
Results: Deviation was found to be very reliable with Cronbach’s alpha values higher than 0.75. There was a statistically significant difference between the groups for lateral deviation range (F(1,26) = 11.373; p = 0.002) and standard deviation (F(1,26) = 10.268; p = 0.004). We observed a statistically significant between-group difference for steering range (F(1,26) = 12.034; p = 0.002), steering standard deviation (F(1,26) = 10.211; p = 0.004) and leaning standard deviation (F(1,26) = 5.219; p = 0.031). No statistically significant difference was present for leaning range (F(1,26 = 1.498; p = 0.232).
Discussion: The results support the first hypothesis by showing that the test used in this study is sensitive to detect differences between novice and expert cyclists and can be used for further research that aims to test the effect of a specific intervention (e.g. training) on bike handling. We also showed that the main motions, which were described before as the main motor control actions in bike handling differ between the novice and expert cyclists in the variability and amplitude. The results of the present study have implications for training designs.
Conclusion: Cycling in a straight line is a valid and sensitive test to evaluate the level of bike handling skills. Inexperienced cyclists control the bike using the same motor control actions as experts, but with an increased variability. -
Effects of changing seat height on bike handling
Background: According to the Statistical Release by the Department for Transport, in the United Kingdom 19.000 cyclists are killed or seriously injured every year, with losing control being one of the most common reasons. Research on bike handling went under a revival, but it is still inconclusive on how humans balance and control trajectories and direction during cycling. Adjusting body position on a bicycle has been previously addressed with an aim to improve physical performance (Ashe et al., 2003, British Journal of Sport Medicine, 37(5), 441-444) or reduce the risk of injury occurrence (Bini et al., 2011, Sports Medicine, 41(6), 463-476). Based on the research and practice, some authors (Burke, 1994, Clinics in Sports Medicine, 13(1), 1-14) designed guidelines based on kinematics and/or morphological measures to properly set up a bicycle. Seat height has been an issue of interest among researchers (Games et al., 2008, The Engineering of Sport, 255-260; Peveler et al., 2005, Journal of Exercise Physiology Online, 8(1), 51-55), but never with an objective of improving bike handling. Therefore, our aim was to test the effects of different seat heights on bike handling.
Methods: 42 participants (18 males (27.1 ± 11.3 years) and 24 females (24.3 ± 7.7 years)) volunteered to take part in this study. Participants were asked to ride a commuting bike for 7 m in the middle of the 60 cm wide cycling lanes as straight as possible. They repeated this task five times at four different seat heights. Initial seat height (100%) was defined as 109 % of the inner leg length. Two lower seat heights (97% and 94%) and one higher (103%) of the initial seat height completed the experimental conditions. Trials at different seat height were carried out in a random order. We assessed lateral deviation from the centre of the lane, steering angle and bike leaning angle (range and standard deviation (SD)). Mean of five trials for each condition were compared among the seat heights by means of repeated measure ANOVA. In case of a statistical significance (p < 0.05), Bonferroni post-hoc tests were used for pairwise comparisons.
Results: We found no statistically significant difference for lateral deviation SD (F(3,123) = 0.927; p = 0.430; ω2 = 0.022) and range (F(3,123) = 0.618; p = 0.605; ω2 = 0.015). There was a statistically significant difference for steering SD (F(3,123) = 4.121; p = 0.008; ω2 = 0.091), steering range (F(3,123) = 4.338; p = 0.006; ω2 = 0.096), leaning SD (F(3,123) = 3.006; p = 0.033; ω2 = 0.068) and range (F(3,123) = 5.971; p = 0.001; ω2 = 0.127). The participants perceived subjectively 97% as the most comfortable seat height to cycle at.
Discussion: Results of the present study showed that seat height does not the accuracy of completing a trial. However, we have observed that cyclists completed the trial using different mechanisms of bike handling depending on the seat height. Variability of leaning is increased at seat heights set higher than the current recommended guidelines. Practical implications of the present study are that seat height should be set to fulfil other aims, e.g. comfort and efficiency. Further research should focus on training schemes to improve bike handling skills and on the effects of changing upper body position and how this affects bike handling. -
Increased physical effort overrides the potentially deleterious effects of resource depletion following self-control
Background: Long duration cycling events require riders to maintain concentration and self-control over lengthy periods, for example, listening to race plans and/or eve-dropping on conversations of other riders whilst maintaining pace and bike control. Self-control is the deliberate effort to override a dominant response such as an emotion or thought with a response perceived to benefit goal attainment. Evidence suggests that self-control is an effortful process that draws upon both physiological and psychological resources (Gailliot et al., 2007: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 92 (2), 325–336). Thus, if effortful self-control draws upon physiological resources, then it could hamper endurance performance which utilises the same physiological substrates. However, recent research has questioned this explanation suggesting self-control might be more about resource allocation (Beedie & Lane, 2012: Personality and Social Psychology Review, 16(2):143-53).
Purpose: The purpose of the present study was to examine the effects of doing self-control tasks on cycle performance and emotion regulation. In a dual-task design, one task (bicycle ride) was personally meaningful and a second task (Stroop task) had unknown personal meaning. We hypothesised that by recruiting participants to a task that was personally meaningful, individuals’ emotions would act as a signal to mobilise resources to overcome the potentially deleterious effects of resource-depletion deriving from the Stroop task. We predicted that performance on the Stroop task would deteriorate as participants re-allocated resources to the primary task.
Methods: 43 participants were randomly assigned to one of two conditions: an experimental condition comprising two self-control tasks performed consecutively and a control condition in which two tasks were performed consecutively but only one required self-control. The procedure was as follows: 1) Stroop task 2) Bicycle ride; 3) Stroop task; 4) Bicycle ride, 5) Stroop task. A modified version of the classic Stroop colour-word task was employed using shapes and colours. In the (non-depleting) control condition, shapes were presented in their respective shape and colour (e.g., the word ‘‘green’’ and shape “triangle” was presented in green ink and as a triangle). In the (depleting) experimental condition, the word and ink colour was incongruent with the shape (e.g., the words “green triangle” appeared below a red square in red font colour). Participants rated their emotions before and after both bicycle rides. They were all asked to rate how important it was to perform well.
Results: Cycle performance results indicated performance was fastest in the second trial (194 + 48s vs 212 + 45s) than the first trial (213 + 39s vs 230 + 41s) with no significant differences between the control and experimental group, hence suggesting the first self-control did not impair performance. Improved performance was matched with increased heart rate across trials for both the control (130 + 19bpm vs 136 + 19bpm) and experimental groups (125 + 22 vs 133 + 21bpm). In contrast, the rate of improvement for the Stroop was significantly faster among the control group compared to the experimental group across all three tasks (18.38 + 5.27 vs 24.17 + 5.67s; 17.54 + 4.86 vs 23.12 + 4.51; 16.39 + 4.70 vs 22.0.8 + 3.25).
Discussion: In support of our hypothesis, bicycle performance improved following completion of the Stroop task. In contrast to previous findings, final Stroop performance also improved suggesting that there could be a transfer effect. Our findings are consistent with recent research that has argued that cognitive and affective theory (Beedie & Lane, 2012) provides a better fit to deficits in self-control than the strength model (Gailliot et al., 2007).
Conclusion: These findings provide experimental evidence that self-control ability is temporarily impaired following a separate, unrelated self-control task. However, if participants are sufficiently motivated to perform well, then increased physical effort may improve self-control behaviour and this appears to transfer across tasks -
The relationship between vertical leg stiffness and gross mechanical efficiency in cyclists
Background: Professional cyclists have been shown to have a mechanical efficiency that is 11% higher compared to amateur cyclists (Coyle et al. 1991: Med Sci Sports Exerc, 23 (1), 93-107). The variations in power between professional and amateur cyclists are associated with a greater torque development at the first phase of the pedal revolution (Coyle et al. 1991). It has also been shown in cyclists that a relationship exists between vertical leg stiffness and the peak power output (PPO) (r = 0.75, p < 0.01) achieved during a 30 s Wingate test (Pitchers et al. 2013: The relationship of vertical leg stiffness, peak power output and V̇O2max in recreationally active cyclists: identification of the interface between human and bike. 9th Annual Conference of the United Kingdom Strength & Conditioning Association, Nottingham, UK). Vertical leg stiffness may be important to cycling performance as the majority of the force produced is vertical and optimisation of the stretch shortening cycle may limit energy wastage during the propulsive phase (So et al. 2005: Phys Ther Sports, 6, 89-96; Fonda & Sarabon 2010: Sport Sci Rev, 19 (1), 187-210). The relationship between vertical leg stiffness and mechanical efficiency during cycling has yet to be examined.
Purpose: To assess the relationship between vertical leg stiffness and gross mechanical efficiency (GE) in cycling.
Methods: In a single group, within subjects design, 11 recreationally active male cyclists (age 34 ± 6 y, V̇O2max 57.4 ± 7.5 ml∙kg∙min-1, body mass 81 ± 1.2 kg, stature 1.81 ± 0.06 m) completed two testing sessions, with a minimum of 48 hr rest between each session. In the first testing session participants completed a stiffness familiarisation before an incremental cycle test to establish V̇O2max. At the second session participants completed 20 sub-maximal bilateral hops at a frequency of 2.3 Hz. This was followed by three 8 min sub-maximal cycling bouts at 50, 55 and 60 % of the participants’ individual maximal minute power (MMP) to establish GE (Table I).
Results: Mean values for GE and vertical leg stiffness were 19.0 ± 1.4 % and 34.1 ± 9.0 kN∙m-1, respectively. Pearson’s correlation coefficient revealed no relationship between vertical leg stiffness and GE (r = -0.07, p = 0.85).
Discussion: The main finding is that in recreationally active male cyclists there is no relationship between vertical leg stiffness and GE. In this group these findings indicate that GE is likely influenced more by other biological systems rather than the mechanical properties of the musculoskeletal system. However, these data may not be reflective of an elite sample where higher leg stiffness might be more likely to influence GE at higher power outputs.
Conclusion: Whilst vertical leg stiffness has been shown to have a strong relationship with PPO (Pitchers et al 2013) in recreational cyclists, this is not the case for GE. Further work is needed to establish if this is also the case in an elite population. -
The influence of hamstring extensibility on preselected saddle height within experienced competitive cyclists
Background: Contemporary studies have investigated the effects of bicycle saddle height for optimal performance and injury prevention. A recent review established a dynamic knee flexion angle of 25˚-30˚ for optimal economy, anaerobic power, and knee tracking (Bini et al., 2011: Sports Medicine, 41, 463-476). Muyor et al, (2011: Journal of Human Kinetics, 29, 15-23), investigated hamstring extensibility within 96 highly trained cyclists. They concluded that shortened hamstrings had a negative influence over thoracic spinal curvature, yet no influence over saddle height. Whereas, Ferrer-Roca et al (2012: Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 26, 3025- 3029) examined 23 high level competitive male road cyclists and concluded that a lack of flexibility may have an influence over lower preselected saddle heights (> 40˚ knee flexion angle). Consequently, there remains uncertainty whether preselected saddle height may be dependent on hamstring extensibility.
Purpose: The purpose of the study was to investigate the influence of hamstring extensibility on preselected saddle height within experienced competitive cyclists. It was suggested that preselected saddle height may be dependent on hamstring extensibility to enable a 25˚-30˚ knee flexion angle.
Methods: Participants consisted of 32 moderate to high level male and female road cyclists (35.8 ± 8.4 years; 178.22 ± 11.0 cm; 77.7 ± 13.4 kg). They used their own individually set-up road bicycle, which was placed on an indoor wind trainer. Hamstring extensibility was measured using the passive knee extension test. Dynamic 2D analysis was used to measure bicycle knee flexion and passive knee extension angles. A cycling questionnaire was also used to determine experience, training and competition levels.
Results: Pearson’s correlation coefficients revealed bicycle knee flexion angle, years cycling (r = -0.35, p < 0.05), training volume, (r = -0.54, p< 0.01) and competition duration (years) (r = -0.62, p< 0.01) were significant. Whereas, no significance was identified with pre (r = 0.12) and post (r = 0.12) passive knee extension (p > 0.05).
Discussion: Results suggest that sustained time period on the bike rather than hamstring extensibility determines preselected saddle height. In particular, being competitive for a longer duration precedes either volume or number of years cycling. However, it is apparent that in agreement with Muyor et al., (2011) a single variable such as hamstring length does not predetermine optimal saddle height. In addition, as suggested by Ferrer-Roca et al., (2012), experienced cyclists are unable to achieve a knee flexion angle of 25˚, unless they have sufficient flexibility.
Conclusion: Results reveal that with experience, a competitive cyclist’s subjective and objective interpretation of their preselected saddle height becomes more consistent. Although hamstring extensibility does not appear to influence pre-selected saddle height, an initial 35˚ rather than 25˚ knee flexion angle is recommended. Future research should consider mixed methodologies, to further establish safe and effective recommendations for optimising bicycle fit. -
Modelling of critical power from road data
Background: Performance tests are an integral part of evaluating competitive cyclists. Despite all technological and physiological advances, limited research has been performed addressing the translation of standardized, relevant laboratory tests into the field and consequently into “real world” cycling (i.e. .(i.e. González-Haro et al., 2007: British Journal of Sports Medicine, 41(3), 174–179; Quod et al., 2010:InterInternational Journal of Sports Medicine, 31(6), 397–401; Nimmerichter et al., 2010: International Journal of Sports Medicine, 31(3), 160- 166). For continuous activities between approximately 2 and 30 minutes, the assessment of Critical Power (CP) is one such relevant test. Compromising ecological validity, to date CP testing is mostly constrained to the laboratory.
Purpose: To investigate a novel CP road testing protocol.
Methods: Laboratory determined CP values using a 30 min intra-trial recovery period (Bishop & Jenkins, 1995: European Journal of Applied Physiology and Occupational Physiology, 72 (1-2), 115-120) were compared with those determined in the field, i.e. on the road. The experiment comprised of planned maximal efforts of 12 min, 7 min and 3 min with a 30 min recovery period between efforts. Linear regression was used to determine CP using the work-time equation (W = CPt + W).
Results: There was no significant difference between laboratory and road CP values. The mean difference between the two environments was 0 ± 5.5 W. The standard error of estimates was 1.7% and limits of agreement were -10.8 – 10.8 W (Fig. 1).
Discussion: Results suggests that CP can be tested on the road. Gonzales-Haro accepted their incremental velodrome field test as being valid with reported limits of agreement of 130 W to – 24 W and a random error of 13.9%. Our limits of agreement values are considerably higher and standard error of estimate values are considerably lower than those reported by Gonzales-Haro. The experimental protocol provides a practical and easy to use alternative to the conventional testing protocol for coaches and athletes when determining CP in on the road.
Conclusion: The aforementioned research provides support for the acceptance of road CP performance testing using a 30 min inter-maximal effort recovery period. -
Efficiency index of a pedaling monitor system depend on load power, cadence and body weight
Background: In recent years, a variety of power meters for bicycles has become commercially available (Allen & Coggan, 2010: Training and Racing with a Power Meter (2nd edn.). Boulder, Velopress). In particular, a pedaling monitoring system (SGY-PM900H90, SGX-CA900: Pioneer Corporation, Kawasaki, Japan) is a device that displays a pedaling force vector to decompose the tangential and normal direction of pedaling force (Pioneer Cyclesports, “Pedaling Monitor Sensor”. Retrieved 20 March, 2014, from http://pioneer-cyclesports.com/us-en/). No other such devices exist except for those used experimentally. This device can display the efficiency index of the pedaling force. Although we can see the pedaling force vector diagram and the efficiency index change every second, it is difficult to understand the state of the averaged pedaling force vectors (Bibbo et al., 2008: A wireless integrated system to evaluate efficiency indexes in real time during cycling, 4th European Conference of the IFMBE Proceedings, 22: 89–92).
Purpose: The purpose of this study was to reveal the influence of load power, cadence, and body weight on the efficiency index of the pedaling monitor system by averaging the pedaling force vector signal obtained from the pedaling monitor system over a measuring period.
Methods: Twenty-eight participants were given the pedaling load step up from ~150 W to ~300 W by a bicycle trainer (Powerbeam Pro-trainer: CycleOps, Madison, WI). The pedaling force vectors during the step load were recorded. Cadence was not specified: each participant had decided on a comfortable cadence. Using a pedaling force vector obtained from the experiment, the pedaling force vector was averaged at each load step, and the efficiency index was determined from the averaged pedaling force vector. Multiple regression analysis was conducted with the efficiency index as an objective variable, and load power, cadence, and body weight were set as explanatory variables.
Results: The efficiency index was significantly correlated (multiple correlation coefficient: r = 0.732, p-value = 4.6 x10-21) with load power (regression coefficient: = 0.078%, p = 3.2 x10-16), cadence (= -0.429%, p = 2.0 x10-10), and body weight (= -0.383%, p = 1.4x10-7). Using the coefficient value of the multiple regression analysis, the efficiency index was compensated to remove the effects of these factors (load power, cadence, and body weight). As a result, the average compensated efficiency index was 50.2% at 250 W, 100 rpm, 65 kg, and the standard deviation was 5.2%.
Discussion: The result was considered to be due to the influence of the load effect, which was applied to the pedal by centrifugal force and gravity of the leg weight. The variation in the compensated efficiency index was small, after removing the effects of load power, cadence, and body weight. It was considered that the features of pedaling of the participant were reflected in the compensated efficiency index. According to the actual pedaling force vector, the effect of downward force in the recovery phase was large.
Conclusion: In order to reveal the influence of load power, cadence, and body weight on the efficiency index of the pedaling force vector, multiple regression analysis was made with the efficiency index calculated from the averaged pedaling force vector. As a result, the following became clear: (1) the efficiency index can be compensated to remove the effects of these factors (load power, cadence, and body weight), and (2) it is possible to understand the features of the participant's pedaling technique from the compensated efficiency index. -
Within-individual haemoglobin variation and the athlete biological passport: a longitudinal investigation of 13,887 haemoglobin concentration readings in elite athletes
The Athlete Biological Passport (ABP), introduced by the Union Cycliste Internationale (UCI) in 2008, has proven a critical tool for the reduction of doping cases. The ABP estimates individual reference ranges for haemoglobin concentration ([Hb]) and percentage reticulocytes from predetermined population mean, between- and within-individual variances. Here, we aim to verify the previously published estimate for within-individual variance of [Hb] (39.86 g2/L2) and determine whether sex-, sport- or season-specific values are required. Our reference population contains 7,723 male (mean ± s, 22.3 ± 4.6 years of age) and 6,164 female (21.6 ± 4.3 years of age) athlete observations from 49 sports. [Hb] was calculated using one of three cytometers; Bayer-H3 (1997 – 1999, n = 4,554), ADVIA-120 (1999 – 2010, n = 8,636) and Sysmex XT-2000i (2010 – 2012, n = 697). Linear mixed models were fitted with [Hb] as the response variable, analysis system (H3, ADVIA, Sysmex), sex (male, female), sport (power endurance, endurance, team, skill, disabled and non-athletes), season (summer, winter) the fixed effects and athlete the random effect. The final model contained an exponential correlation structure for the within-individual variance and allowed different within-individual variances for each sport.Within-individual [Hb] variance was spatially correlated up to 36.5 days (95% CI 28.3 – 47.1) between measures. The proportion of within-individual variance that is analytical in origin was estimated as 0.54 (95% CI 0.50 - 0.60). Within-individual [Hb] variance did not differ between sexes (37.54 males, 37.79 females g2/L2) but was significantly less for power endurance, disabled and non-athletes than for endurance and team sports athletes and significantly higher during the hot months. In conclusion, the current estimate of within-individual [Hb] variance is accurate and no new evidence was found to justify adjusting this value. -
Multisensor monitoring cycle ergometer
Cycling ergometers provide a repeatable and controllable test setup to observe the effect that the mechanical (e.g. frame geometry), biomechanical (e.g. position on the bicycle) or biophysical (e.g. effect of rider position on heart rate) variables have over an athlete’s performance, hence their widespread use (Peveler, 2008: Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 22(4), 1355-1359) (Wergel-Kolmert, 2002: Clinical Physiology & Functional Imaging, 22(4), 261-265). Although authors have addressed the accuracy of the different types of ergometers available (i.e. air-braked, electromagnetically-braked, friction-braked, mobile) the question of which characteristics apart from accuracy serve as evaluation criteria to determine the quality of an ergometer remains (Paton, 2001: Hopkins Sports Med; 31(7): p489-496) (Mori & Belli , 2004: Journal of Biomechanics, 37, 141-145). A set of evaluation criteria that includes functional, technical and ease of use aspects were proposed. These criteria included input from not only the coaches/biomechanists but also from the system designer, allowing fulfilment of the user’s requirements whilst maintaining enough flexibility to adapt to changes (e.g. integration of new sensors).A novel, fully automated cycling ergometer with integrated multi-sensor modalities has been designed, enabling cycle geometry setup within 80 seconds for first setup (and 17 seconds for subsequent setups). Built upon a robust industrial data communication protocol (Controller Area Network (CAN)) the ergometer allows (1) integration of multiple sensors (e.g. instrumented cranks) and (2) real-time data acquisition. Instrumented cranks provide right/left torque and force through 360 degrees of crank revolution (as seen in Figure 1B). Inclusion of 3-D motion analysis techniques such as CODA has been used to validate the effect of different rider positions and resistance profiles on the angles of both ankle and hip (ankle angle for three different resistance profiles illustrated by Figure 1A). Variable load profiles (i.e. constant cadence, constant torque) can be implemented using feedback from (1) the left crank, (2) the right crank, (3) both cranks and (4) a torque transducer which is in line with the motor used to provide the pedalling load. The controller strategy allows for fine tuning of its parameters to allow an aspect not considered during ergometer design, that is the perception or ‘feel’ of a bicycle. A set of tests to both construct a vocabulary that can be used to evaluate the perception and establish the controller parameters that provide the best ‘feel’ have been designed. The presented ergometer supports rapid and precise configuration for athlete setup preferences and inclusion of torque and velocity profiles. By using standard bicycle components changes can be handled quickly. Industrial communications protocol provides not only a robust method for acquisition of sensor signal but also the flexibility to add new functionality if required. The use of different controller feedbacks permits (1) achieving the perception of the ergometer as a real bicycle and (2) inclusion of mathematical models of power to replicate road based cycling. -
Reliability of power meter calibration by mathematical modelling of treadmill cycling
New power meters that are installed on various parts of the bike entered the market recently. Calibration of power meters is essential to ensure correct power output readings for testing and training. The use of a dynamic calibration rig was proposed as the preferred method to calibrate cycle ergometers (Woods et al., 1994: International Journal of Sports Medicine, 15(4), 168-171). While this works for power meters that measure power output after its transmission through the crank axle, it is not suitable for systems installed on the pedals or the crank arm (e.g. Garmin Vector, Kéo Power, Stages, Rotor Power). Therefore, we want to propose a new method to dynamically calibrate all available power meters. The purpose of our study was to quantify the typical error of this method used to assess load characteristics of power meters.
Thirty power meters (14 SRM, 8 Powertap, 5 Quarq, 3 Garmin Vector) mainly used by cyclists of the Swiss national mountain bike team were analysed. Each cyclist rode his own bike equipped with his power meter on a motorized treadmill (Poma, Dürrröhrsdorf-Dittersbach, Germany), after executing all calibration procedures according to the manufacturer. Cyclists rode with a velocity v = 3.5 m s-1 at an inclination of α1 = 1° and α2 = 7°. These corresponded to power demands of approximately 1 W kg-1 and 5 W kg-1, respectively. Power output measurements were averaged over 1 min for both inclinations. The total mass m of the cyclist, his equipment and bike was measured on a calibrated scale (Model 861, Seca, Reinach, Switzerland). To eliminate any contribution of rolling or aerodynamic resistance, the difference in power output between the two inclinations was calculated as ΔP = m ∙ g ∙ v ∙ (sinα2 – sinα1). The ratio between the measured difference and that calculated by the mathematical model was defined as the load characteristic of the power meter. A value of 1 indicates perfect agreement between the measurement and the model. The procedure was performed twice. The typical error of measurement and its 95% confidence interval for the load characteristic was calculated from the 30 repeated trials (Hopkins, 2000: Sports Medicine, 30(1), 1-15).
The typical error for the load characteristic was 1.5% with a 95% confidence interval of 1.1% to 1.9%. The change in the mean from trial 1 to trial 2 was 0.1% with a 95% confidence interval of -0.7% to 0.9%.
The typical error of 1.5% demonstrates a high reliability of the method used to assess the load characteristic of a power meter, which can easily be enhanced by performing multiple trials. The value for a convenient triple measurement follows as 1.5% / 31/2 = 0.9% (Hopkins, 2000). The typical error presented here is comparable to the reliability reported for the calibration with a dynamic calibration rig (Woods et al., 1994). Our calibration method is easy to administer, time efficient and independent of the power meter system, rolling resistance or cyclist riding style. Even though the method does not assess absolute power output readings, it detects systematic measurement error. To further evaluate the load characteristic, an assumption concerning the drivetrain loss is necessary. After personal communication with J. Smith (www.friction-facts.com, December 6, 2013), we assume a drivetrain loss of 2% in power output difference scores. A valid system located on the crank would therefore measure a 2% higher difference in power output than predicted by the mathematical model. We conclude, that calibrating power meters by mathematical modelling of treadmill cycling is highly reliable and convenient. -
Relation between lactic acid steady-state and muscle oxygenation in elite cyclists
Background & Purpose. In cycling, several physiological values are taken into account to evaluate the performance level of each athlete and/or to plan his training program. One of these values is the maximal power output corresponding to the lactic acid steady-state. To find this power value, it is necessary to test the athlete by an incremental protocol to collect all the physiological parameters necessary to program a subsequent square-wave test, during which it is possible to measure directly this power output. This procedure takes a long time. Bellotti et al. showed that the lactic acid steady-state may be determined by measuring the deoxygenated haemoglobin by NIRS technique in healthy subjects (Bellotti et al., 2013: Med Sci Sports Exerc. 45(6): pp1208-16). We wanted to verify if it is possible, in elite cyclists, to detect the power output corresponding to the lactic acid steady-state using the NIRS technique during a single incremental test.Methods. The experiment was carried on 15 male, elite cyclists participating in international U23 races: 212 years, 1.760.08 m, 66.16.9 kg (avgs, n=15). We used an incremental protocol on a stationary bike (Monark 818 equipped with SRM system, Figure 1 left) consisting on five loads of 360 s each, starting from 0.85 w kg-1 followed by 1w kg-1 increment until the last load at 4.85 w kg-1. Total and oxygenated haemoglobin (tHb and HbO2) were continuously measured in the vastus lateralis of the left quadriceps muscle by NIRS technique (Figure 1 right, NIMO, NIROX, Brescia, Italy), and lactic acid concentration (AL) was measured by Accusport (Bishop, 2011: Sport Med, 22, pp525-530) at 180 s and the end of the last three loads defined as Wlow = 2.970.12 w kg-1, Wmedium =3.930.11 w kg-1 and Whigh = 4.900.14 w kg-1 (avgs, n=15). Pedalling cadence was 1.5÷1.6 Hz. We calculated the time variation of AL (AL/t) and the time rate of tHb and HbO2 (tHb/t and HbO2/t) by a linear interpolation of the NIRS data during the time interval between 180 s and the end of Wlow, Wmedium and Whigh. Twelve participants completed the entire protocol whereas three stopped between 300 and 320 s of Whigh.Results and Discussion. Figure 2 shows a typical experimental record. The subject pedals against the incremental load (continuous line) while muscular oxygenation (dotted line) and AL (point and continuous line) were measured during the last three loads. During exercise at Wlow, all the participants showed an increase both of tHb (upper trace) and HbO2 (intermediate trace) due to peripheral vasodilatation (Grassi et al. 1999: J Appl Physiol; 87, pp348-355). The values of AL at 180 s of Wlow (3.10.8 mM; avgs, n=15) were always greater than AL at the end of Wlow and seemed to be too high for elite athletes. This result may be due to early lactate production; at the end of Wlow, AL decreased to a value compatible with the mechanical power at that moment (1.70.5 mM; avgs, n=15). During exercise at Wmedium the participants reached the AL steady-state: there was no difference between AL measured at 180 s and 360 s (2.30.6 vs 2.70.7 mM; avgs, n=15) and AL/t is 1.792.19 µM s-1 (avgs, n=15). NIRS measurements showed that the muscle oxygenation was about constant: tHb/t and HbO2/t were - 0.00240.0081 µM s-1and -0.00610.0124 µM s-1 respectively (avgs, n=15). Figure 3 shows AL/ttHb/t and HbO2/t plotted as a function of power output; note that the linear function of AL/t (continuous line) and HbO2/t (dotted line) reach zero at the same point very near to a Wmedium. According to Grassi (1999), during and incremental exercise, the onset of lactic acid accumulation is related the beginning of the haemoglobin desaturation. During exercise at Whigh we measured a sharp increase of AL and a decrease of muscle oxygenation: AL/t was 12.768.11 µM s-1 (avgs, n=15) and tHb/t and HbO2/t were -0.00970.0165 µMs-1; and -0.01500.0151 µMs-1 respectively; (avgs, n=15).Figure 4 shows AL/t as a function of HbO2/t. The linear function through all the experimental data passed very close to the axis origin, showing a strong relation between the AL steady-state and the HbO2 steady-state. This point of coincidence is very near to Wmedium.Conclusion. We measured the AL steady-state at 3.75 w kg-1 and the muscular oxygenation steady-state at 3.74 w kg-1. This suggest that it is possible to determine the power output corresponding to the AL steady-state during in incremental protocol, only measuring the muscular oxygenation by NIRS technique. -
Track tales: A narrative exploration of within-career transition in sprint cycling
Background: Although a considerable amount of literature is dedicated to the final transition of retirement, relatively little research focuses on within-career transition. Such a dearth of research may originate from the theoretical and methodological training that sport psychologists receive. The current study will focus on the diversity of the qualitative approaches on offer, in particular the benefits of utilising a constructivist ontological stance.Purpose: The aim of the study is to investigate the within-career transition of two track sprint cyclists, and their coach, as they move from a competitive to an elite sphereMethodology: A constructivist, narrative, approach was used to explore the transition. This approach uses the collective methodologies of ethnography, narrative analysis and autoethnography in order to triangulate and ‘ground’ the narratives in the context of the participant’s lives. Results: Three short stories are presented, along with an overview of the participant’s athletic context and a reflective piece from the writer. The aim was to i) allow the ‘voices’ of the participants to be fore grounded to provide an idiographic account of within-career transitions ii) to examine how the ‘situatedness’ or contextual influences that surrounded the individual impacted on their transition and iii) examine if a narrative approach may act as a supportive mechanism to the participants during the transitional period, not just document its progression.Discussion: The researchers own reflections are suggested, and centre around the nature of individual transitions, the perceived importance of age in sprinting, and also how the process involved in creating transitional stories can be therapeutic in orientation.Conclusions: The aim of the study is to encourage the reader to reflect on the transitions faced in the three stories. Such reflection will hopefully generate debate and dialogue in relation to within-career transitions -
Potentiation of sprint cycling performance: the effects of a high-inertia ergometer warm-up
Background: Individual response to acute post-activation potentiation (PAP) stimulation is affected by factors such as the conditioning protocol design, training status, and biomechanical similarity of the conditioning activity to the goal movement. Purpose: This study tested the effect of a biomechanically comparable PAP conditioning activity on various aspects of standing start sprint cycling performance. Optimal conditions for observing PAP were provided by utilising highly-trained sprint cycling-athletes and a commonly successful protocol executed on a specially built high-inertia cycle ergometer. Methods: Employing a randomized, counterbalanced, cross-over design with repeated measures, four male and two female national and international competitive sprint cyclists (19.2 3.2; mean s yrs; height 175.2 7.0 cm; body mass 75.5 9.8 kg; training years (sprint cycling) 4.0 1.5 years; training years (strength) 3.5 1.2 years; peak isometric pedal torque 255.9 37.8 Nm) executed multiple sets of short maximal conditioning contractions (CC) on a custom-built high-inertia ergometer prior to metered sprint performance. Three trial conditions were completed on three separate days: a standardised warm-up followed by either dynamic (DYN: 4 x 4 complete crank cycles), or isometric (ISO: 4 x 5-second MVC) CC, or a control condition (CON) with active rest for the total equivalent time post-warm-up. Performance was assessed in a short (~6 seconds) maximal acceleration from standing start to maximum velocity on an inertial-load ergometer at baseline (Pre), 4 (Post4), 8 (Post8) and 16 (Post16) minutes following the CC protocol. Torque-cadence and power-cadence relationships were derived from crank data. Performance time, and peak and average biomechanical measures were assessed over four discrete sprint segments. Outcomes were assessed using 2-way repeated measures ANOVA and magnitude-based inferences. Results: Only in DYN Post4 was performance time improved, affecting a 3.9 ± 3.7% (92% likelihood of exceeding smallest worthwhile change (SWC)) decrease in time over the first segment of the sprint. Biomechanical improvements in this trial were predominantly on the ascending limb of the power-cadence relationship, increasing peak torque by 6.2 ± 5.9% (94% SWC) and increasing average power during initial acceleration by 4.0 ± 6.5% (87% SWC). Conversely, ISO Post16 enhanced performance over the descending limb of the power-cadence relationship, affecting an increase in optimal cadence (82% SWC) and augmenting average power (76% SWC) during the maximal velocity phase of the sprint. Discussion: The dynamic and isometric trials contrasted in potentiating opposite extremities of the torque-cadence relation at distinct recovery-times post-CC. Results suggest the predominance of different PAP mechanisms in each trial condition. Conclusion: This study provisionally suggests merit in including a high-inertial component in the sprint warm-up. Performance improvements may include improved starting acceleration or finishing speed, where compromise in gear and pedal length selection strategies would, otherwise, impose limitations on performance. -
Do 3-min all-out test parameters accurately predict competitive cyclist performance in the severe intensity domain?
Background: It is well established that the critical power (CP) and the fixed amount of work performed above the CP (W’) predict performance in the severe intensity domain, and that this two parameters can be successfully obtained from a 3-min all-out test (AOT) (Jones et al., 2010: Med Sci Sports Exerc, 42(10), 1876-90). While the CP obtained from the 3-min AOT has been reported to lay on the boundary between the heavy and severe intensity domains in recreationally active individuals (Jones et al., 2010), it has been reported to overestimate this exercise intensity in competitive cyclists (Sperlich et al., 2011: Int J Sports Med, 32(6), 433-7). It could be therefore hypothesized that CP and W’ obtained from a 3-min AOT test in competitive cyclists overestimate performance in the severe intensity domain. However, this remains to be verified.Purpose: To investigate whether performance in the severe intensity domain can be accurately predicted by CP and W’ obtained from a 3-min AOT test in competitive cyclists. Methods: Nine well-trained competitive cyclists (22 ± 3 yrs) visited the laboratory on four different occasions to perform: 1) a preliminary incremental ramp exercise test; 2) a 3-min AOT familiarization trial; 3) an experimental 3-min AOT and 4) a 10-min time trial (TT). The mean power output of the 10-min TT was compared with the power output that would be predicted to lead to exhaustion in 10 min. The predicted value was obtained according to the formula: P = (W’/TTE) + CP; where TTE is the predicted time to exhaustion (i.e. 600s), and CP (in W) and W’ (in kJ) are the two parameters obtained from the 3-min AOT.Results: Predicted power output (383 ± 44 W) was significantly higher compared to actual mean power output in the 10-min TT (351 ± 29 W; P < 0.01; mean difference: 32.5 ± 25 W). However, actual and predicted performance were correlated (r = 0.84; P < 0.01). Percentage difference between actual and predicted performance was positively related with the CP (r = 0.74; P < 0.05). No difference in VO2max values was found between the ramp incremental test (67 ± 9 ml•kg-1•min-1) and the experimental 3-min AOT (66 ± 5 ml•kg-1•min-1), and a significant correlation was found (r = 0.71; P < 0.05). W’ and CP mean values were 14.1 ± 3 kJ and 360 ± 47 W, respectively.Discussion and conclusions: The CP and the W’ obtained from a 3-min AOT overestimate performance in a 10-min TT in competitive cyclists. This indicates that the two parameters do not provide an accurate prediction of performance in the severe intensity domain. This is particularly evident for cyclists with relatively high CP values. The present data suggest caution when using parameters obtained from a 3-min AOT to monitor and prescribe exercise training in competitive cyclists. -
Oxygen uptake kinetics during uphill and flat cycling in laboratory and field conditions
Background: Previous studies have shown ~5% higher power outputs during a 20-min uphill time-trial¬ compared to a flat time-trial (Nimmerichter et al., 2012: European Journal of Applied Physiology, 112(1), 69-78) and a more even distribution of torque during the pedal revolution during uphill cycling on a treadmill (Arkesteijn et al., 2013: Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 45(5), 920-926). Purpose: To analyse the effect of gradient, cadence and intensity on the primary response of oxygen uptake in laboratory and field conditions.Methods: Thirteen trained cyclists (mean ± s: age 23 ± 5 years; stature 178.5 ± 5.2 cm; body mass 68.7 ± 7.8 kg) performed an incremental ergometer test to determine Pmax (403 ± 43 Watt), V ̇O2max (68.2 ± 4.7 mL∙min-1∙kg-1), the first ventilatory threshold (VT) and the intensity corresponding to 70% (Δ70%) between VT and Pmax. On two separate days the participants performed four trials of 6-min in a seated position on level ground (1.5%) and uphill cycling (5%) at 60 and 90 rev.min-1 at two exercise intensities at 90%VT (159 ± 20 W) and Δ70% (336 ± 35 W) in laboratory and field conditions. Power output was measured with a SRM professional power crank (Schoberer Rad-Messtechnik, Jülich, Germany), which was mounted on a 26-inch mountain bike. To simulate the gradient in laboratory conditions, the bicycle was mounted on an indoor trainer (TACX Elite, Netherlands) and was fixed on a treadmill. Oxygen uptake was measured breath-by-breath with a portable gas analyser (MetaMax3B, CORTEX, Germany). The V ̇O2 breath-by-breath data were interpolated at 1-second intervals and the time constant and the amplitude of the exponential primary phase were resolved by least square regression (GraphPad Prism 6.0, GraphPad Software, USA). A factorial ANOVA with gradient, cadence, intensity and condition as model factors was used for statistical analyses. The level of significance was accepted at P < 0.05. Results: The time constant was significantly affected by the gradient (F1,12 = 10.3, P = 0.008; uphill: 17.9 ± 2.6 sec, flat: 20.9 ± 2.1 sec), the cadence (F1,12 = 5.0, P = 0.045; 60 rev.min-1: 20.3 ± 2.5 sec, 90 rev.min-1: 18.5 ± 1.8 sec) and the intensity (F1,12 = 15.8, P = 0.002; 90%VT: 17.2 ± 2.5 sec, Δ70%: 21.6 ± 2.7 sec). No significant difference was observed between laboratory (19.2 ± 2.1 sec) and field conditions (19.6 ± 2.2 sec) (F1,12 = 0.3, P = 0.613). The amplitude was significantly affected by the cadence (F1,12 = 97.7, P < 0.001; 60 rev.min-1: 1818 ± 95 mL, 90 rev.min-1: 2083 ± 249 mL), the intensity (F1,12 = 425.2, P < 0.001; 90%VT: 1292 ± 234 mL, Δ70%: 2608 ± 260 mL) and the condition (F1,12 = 6.8, P = 0.023; field: 2040 ± 281 mL, laboratory: 1861 ± 216 mL). No significant difference was observed between uphill (1969 ± 213 mL) and flat cycling (1932 ± 234 mL) (F1,12 = 1.5, P = 0.244).Discussion: The faster oxidative response observed during uphill compared to flat cycling reduce the oxygen deficit, can improve exercise tolerance and therefore can possibly increase performance. Although the amplitude was significantly higher at the higher-cadence, the V ̇O2 on-kinetics were significantly faster. Thus, a high-cadence starting strategy at the onset of exercise might be beneficial. The higher amplitude during field compared to laboratory conditions indicate an increased energy demand during outdoor cycling -
Changes in whole body and local muscle oxygen consumption during prolonged cycling
Background: Cycling efficiency is a measure of the power output to power input and is a key determinant of cycling performance (Hopker et al., 2013: Journal of Applied Physiology, 115, 723-729). However, the determinants of cycling efficiency are yet to be fully elucidated. Past research has demonstrated that the majority of energetic cost that arises from endurance exercise can be attributed to the exercising muscle (Poole et al., 1992: Journal of Applied Physiology, 72, 805-810), however cycling efficiency is commonly determined by measuring pulmonary oxygen consumption. Purpose: This study aimed to investigate whether cycling efficiency calculated from pulmonary oxygen uptake was reflective of indices of local muscle oxygenation and oxygen consumption measured by near-infrared spectroscopy.Methods: Thirteen competitive cyclists (30 ± 14 years, 173 ± 10 cm, 73 ± 2 mL.kg-1.min-1) performed a 120-minute bout of steady state cycling at 60 % maximum minute power (MMP), determined from a preceding maximal incremental exercise test performed on a separate occasion. Measurements of expired air were taken at minute 5 and then every 30 minutes throughout the rest of the steady state trial. Power input was calculated from the measured VO2 and its energetic equivalent according to the nonprotein respiratory quotient. Power output was recorded as the average power output over the gas collection time. Cycling Gross Efficiency (GE) was calculated as the product of work accomplished / energy expended x 100%. Near-infrared spectroscopy was used to assess the Tissue Saturation Index (TSI%), oxygenated hemoglobin (O2Hb), deoxygenated hemoglobin (HHb), total hemoglobin (tHb) and muscle oxygen consumption (mVO2) of the Vastus Lateralis muscle. NIRS measurements were taken at the same time as sampling of expired gases. To normalize the concentration changes in the NIRS signal, a 2-minute resting baseline was recorded prior to the cycling bout, which was then subtracted from all the NIRS measurements (except TSI%). Data were analysed using repeated measures ANOVA to assess changes over time. Results: As shown in Figure 1, GE significantly decreased over the duration of the steady state cycling trial (p=0.002), as did TSI% (p<0.001). O2Hb increased over time, but this was not significant (p=0.332). Both HHb and tHb significantly increased over time (p<0.01). There was a mean increase in mVO2 over the first 30 minutes of exercise, but then a progressive decrease for the remaining 90 minutes of the trial. However changes were not significant (p=0.289). Discussion: Tissue oxygenation of the Vastus Lateralis muscle significantly reduced over the 2-hour bout of cycling, which was mirrored by reductions in GE. The largest reductions in TSI% and GE occurred during the first 30 minutes of the trial, which is also reflected in the HbO2 concentration. tHb increased over the 2-hours cycling suggesting increased central delivery to the working muscle in an attempt to maintain the level of oxygen availability to the working muscle. However, it can be seen from the TSI(%) and mVO2 that tissue oxygenation and muscle oxygen consumption both decline over the 2–hour period of cycling. Conclusion: Reductions in muscle tissue oxygenation and mVO2 during 2-hours of cycling at mirrored by GE calculated from whole body oxygen consumption. -
Effect of environmental temperature on pacing during a simulated 16 km cycling time trial
Background: In cycling time trials (TT) the aim is to produce greatest average power possible for the duration of the effort; to do this an athlete must distribute their effort efficiently to ensure that they do not fatigue early but finish the event having exhausted their energy stores (Atkinson et al, 2007: Sports Medicine, 37, 647-667). This distribution of effort is initially determined by conscious control (selection of a pacing strategy), but is influenced by afferent feedback from both internal sensations and environmental factors (St. Clair Gibson & Noakes, 2004: British Journal of Sports Medicine, 38, 797-806). Performance in prolonged endurance exercise is inversely related to environmental temperature; this is thought to be due to central nervous system regulation of effort in response to increased core temperature. While this negative effect of hot conditions on TT performance is well established, less is known about the effect of environmental temperature on pacing during TT efforts, in particular in short time trials which are common in amateur cycling as well as in professional stage races such as the Grand Tours. Purpose: The aim of this study was to examine the effect of environmental temperature on performance and pacing during a simulated 16 km cycling time trial.Methods: After familiarisation, six moderately trained male cyclists (age (mean ± s) 20 ± 1 year; VO2max 45.3 ± 7.3 ml.kg-1.min-1, power at VO2max 312 ± 28 W) completed self-paced 22-minute trials on an electromagnetically-braked cycle ergometer in hot (30ºC, HOT) and temperate (15ºC, COOL) conditions. Participants were instructed to complete as much work as possible during the trial and the only feedback provided was cadence and time with 5 and 1 minute remaining. Heart rate, core temperature and rate of perceived exertion were recorded at two minute intervals.Results: Mean power was slightly lower in HOT than COOL (201 ± 38 W vs. 209 ± 43 W); the difference was not significant. Core temperature and heart rate were both significantly higher in HOT than COOL (temperature: 37.3 ± 0.5 ºC vs. 36.4 ± 0.9 ºC; heart rate: 173 ± 7 bpm vs. 166 ± 11 bpm); rating of perceived exertion did not differ between the two conditions. Pacing appeared to differ slightly: when power output was compared across four quarters of the time trial the athletes adopted a positive split with end-spurt in HOT (Q1: 103% overall mean power, Q2: 100%, Q3: 97%, Q4: 100%) and a negative split with end-spurt in COOL (Q1: 97% overall mean power, Q2: 98%, Q3: 99%, Q4: 107%); the difference was significant in the last quarter.Discussion: The main outcome of this study was that pacing strategy differed slightly with environmental conditions, despite relatively similar overall performances in both trials. The effect of environmental conditions on pacing and the mechanisms involved warrant further investigation, given the important of pacing in successful time trial performance for athletes who train and compete under a range of environmental conditions. -
Comparing time-trial and time to exhaustion performance
Introduction: Time to exhaustion trials (TTE) at a fixed exercise intensity have been widely used in a laboratory setting to measure endurance performance. However, they have been criticised for lacking ecological validity compared with laboratory time-trials (TT). Therefore we hypothesised that competitive cyclists would perform better in a TT than TTE over the same duration.Method: Ten male competitive cyclists (mass 69.5 ± 7.9 kg, VO2max (60 ± 7.6 ml∙kg-1∙min-1) completed 3 TTE trials at 80, 100 and 105% of VO2max. On a second visit the cyclists were asked to perform 3 TT’s of the same duration as the first visit. On this occasion the cyclists were asked to average the highest power output possible. During both visits riders received no feedback on their power output or elapsed time during the rides. Average power output, RPE after 1 and 5 minutes of each trial were recorded. These measurements were compared with a paired t-test, where statistical significance was assumed at P<0.05.Results: No difference in measurements between TT and TTE was found for the average power output at 100 or 105% VO2max (354 ± 68 vs. 352 ± 56 W, and 374 ± 59 vs. 378 ± 55 W, P>0.05, respectively). Average power output at 80% VO2max was significantly lower for TT vs. TTE (292 ± 35 vs. 300 ± 36 W, P<0.05 respectively), although no difference was found in RPE (P>0.05).Conclusion: Performance in TT and TTE trials at high intensity is not different for competitive cyclists. However, at 80% VO2max TT average power output is lower suggesting that riders were unable to pace the trial as effectively. -
Effects of a seven day period of high-intensity training on performance and physiology of competitive cyclists
Background: Competitive endurance cyclists commonly undertake periods of intensified overload training in the weeks prior to major competitions in order to bring themselves to optimal levels of fitness. Purpose: In this investigation we examine the effects of two seven-day high-intensity overload training regimes (HIT) on changes in performance and physiological characteristics of well-trained competitive cyclists. Methods: Twenty-eight male cyclists (mean ± SD, Age: 33 ± 10 years, Mass 74 ± 7 kg, VO2 max 4.7 ± 0.5 L.min-1) were assigned to a control group or one of two training groups for seven consecutive days of high intensity training. HIT sessions were ~90 minutes in duration and consisted of matched volumes of 5, 10 and 20 second (short) or 15, 30 and 45 second (long) maximal self-paced intensity efforts with a 1:5 work to recovery ratio. Before and after the training cyclists completed an ergometer based incremental exercise test and a computer simulated 20-km hilly time-trial to assess both performance and physiological characteristics. Results: Relative to the control group, the mean changes (± 90% confidence limits) in time-trial power were 8.2% ± 3.8% and 10.4% ± 4.3% for the short and long HIT regimes respectively; corresponding increases in peak power in the incremental test following training were 5.5% ± 2.7% and 9.5% ± 2.5%. Both HIT (short vs long) interventions led to increases (mean ± SD) in VO2 max (2.3% ± 4.7% vs 3.5% ± 6.2%), lactate threshold power (3.6% ± 3.5% vs 2.9% ± 5.3%) and gross efficiency (3.2% ± 2.4% vs 5.1% ± 3.9%) with only small differences between the two HIT regimes. There were no substantial changes in the control group for either performance or physiological measures.Discussion: Seven days of overload HIT induces substantial increases in time-trial performance with competitive cyclists. The increases in performance were associated with gains in most physiological measures commonly associated with endurance performance. The magnitude of change in physiological variables was dependent upon the particular type of training performed; however there were generally only trivial or small differences in performance and physiological gains between the two training interventions.Conclusions: We conclude that inclusion of seven days of intensified training prior to competition can lead to substantial increases in performance and physiological characteristics. It is also likely that HIT consisting of longer duration intervals is the more effective training regime with this subject sample. -
Low dose fish oil increases the omega-3 index improving cycling efficiency and heart rate recovery
Background: Dietary fish oil provides long chain omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids (LC n-3 PUFA) eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). The heart (Charnock et al., 1986: Annals of Nutrition and Metabolism, 30, 393-406) and skeletal muscle (Peoples & McLennan, 2010: British Journal of Nutrition, 104(12), 1771-1779) preferentially incorporate DHA and modulates both myocardial (Pepe & McLennan, 2002: Circulation, 105, 2303-2308) and skeletal muscle oxygen consumption translated as improved muscle fatigue resistance (Peoples & McLennan, 2014: British Journal of Nutrition, 111, 996-1004). However, studies of well-trained endurance athletes have used excessive doses of DHA (Peoples et al., 2008: Journal of Cardiovascular Pharmacology, 52, 540-547; Buckley et al., 2009: Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport, 12(4), 503-507). Given that even a very low fish oil supplement maximises membrane incorporation of DHA (Slee et al., 2010: Journal of Lipid Research, 51, 1841-1847) there is strong physiological basis for cyclists to improve oxygen efficiency through a nutritional approach. Purpose: The current study primarily aimed to establish if provision of a low dose of dietary fish oil in cyclists could convey improved oxygen efficiency in heart and skeletal muscle under conditions of established cycling fatigue and acute recovery. Methods: Using a double-blind design, trained males (N=26) were supplemented with (2x1g.d-1) soy oil (control n=13) or tuna fish oil (FO n=13) providing LCn-3PUFA, DHA: 560mg and EPA: 140mg (Nu-Mega, Australia) for 8 weeks. Erythrocyte omega-3 index (% EPA+DHA) was measured at baseline at following supplementation. At both time points participants underwent a repeated Wingate cycling protocol (6x30sec / 150seconds recovery) to establish cycling fatigue, immediately followed by a 5min cycling time trial (Wattbike, UK). Upon completion, participants were place in a supine recovery position for 10mins. Oxygen consumption (O2), heart rate (HR) and power (W) were continuously monitored.Results: Erythrocyte omega-3 index at baseline (Control: 4.2±0.2; FO: 4.7±0.2%) was not different between groups. After 8weeks the omega-3 index was unchanged in control (3.9±0.2%) but increased in FO group (6.3±0.3%, P< 0.01). There was no effect of FO supplementation on; peak HR (Control: 174±1 FO: 176±1beats.min-1), mean power during Wingate cycling fatigue protocol (Control: 545±28; FO: 511±33W), or cycling time trial performance under established fatigue (Control: 267±19; FO: 253±16W). However, FO supplementation improved oxygen efficiency (delta change) during the cycling time trial (Control: -23±26; FO: -154±59ml O2/min/100W P<0.05) and accelerated HR recovery (logit half-time) in the supine position immediately afterwards (Control: -0.4±1.2s; FO: -8.0±1.7s, P<0.05). The later was independent of a change in parasympathetic tone and reflective of reduced myocardial oxygen consumption.Discussion: A low dose fish oil supplement providing DHA increased the omega-3 index in trained cyclists. The improved cycling efficiency is reflective of the oxygen modulation previously demonstrated in rodent skeletal muscle (Peoples & McLennan, 2014), while the faster heart rate recovery without alteration in autonomic tone is supportive of the a reduction in intrinsic beat rate of the SA node following DHA administration (Verkerk, et al., 2009: Heart Rhythm, 6(10), 1485-1492). Conclusion: Provision of LCn-3 PUFA, DHA, in the form of a low dose fish oil supplement can have profound effects on heart and skeletal muscle incorporation, and as consequence improve cycling efficiency and heart rate recovery, indicative of reduced heart load. As a consequence, the concentrations used in the current study can be modeled for nutritional recommendations of DHA in elite cyclists. -
The effect of wheel diameter on vertical and horizontal mountain bike position
Background: Mountain bike wheel dimensions have evolved to larger diameters in recent years. While numerous claims can be found for performance advantages of larger diameter wheels, systematic comparisons of mechanical characteristics are not available.Purpose: Compare the change in velocity and the variability of vertical position between 26 and 29 inch diameter mountain bike wheels while rolling across a straight 10 m long bumpy track over a range of velocities. Methods: Horizontal and vertical bike position data were collected across a straight wooden track (10 m) with an assortment of 21 randomly spaced wooden bumps ranging in size from 1.75 to 7.5 cm. Position data were recorded at 200 Hz using a 10 camera Vicon System with a reflective marker attached to the stem. Two front wheels (Stan's NoTubes ZTR Crest, Maxxis Ardent tire, 26 psi inflation, tubeless) were matched in all characteristics except diameter and mass. Mass differed by about 100 g (7%). A carbon, hardtail frame (Niner Air 9) was used throughout with 29 inch rear wheel; 26 and 29 inch front wheels were exchanged between conditions. Rigid (White Brothers Rocksolid) and suspension (Rockshox Reba) front forks were tested with each wheel condition. For each wheel/fork combination 10 trials were ridden with increasing speeds that ranged from 3 to 8 m/s. Conditions were randomized with the rider (male, 30 yrs) riding passively without lifting or pedaling during each trial. Analysis of covariance was used to compare conditions with speed as the covariate. Linear regression was used to assess the relationship of the change in velocity to incoming velocity and the variability of vertical position to incoming velocity.Results: There was no significant difference for all wheel/fork conditions with the change in velocity (suspension; p = 0.4523, rigid; p = 0.4164). The variability of vertical position with a rigid fork and 29 inch wheel was significantly greater (p = 0.0004) than with the 26 inch wheel. With the suspension fork, there was a small but significant difference (p = 0.0006) with the 29 inch wheel over the 26 inch wheel.Discussion: Wheel diameter had no significant influence on the change in velocity of the bike. However, for both fork conditions, the variability of vertical position was significant between the 29 and 26 inch wheels. The larger wheel experienced a greater vertical motion due to the mechanics of the wheel. The larger diameter of the 29 inch wheel translated to more contact time with each bump causing more vertical motion. This difference was seen in both fork conditions, albeit much smaller with the suspension fork. For each wheel/fork condition, the change in velocity decreased as the incoming velocity increase. For both wheel diameters with the suspension fork, the vertical motion decreased as incoming velocity increased, whereas with the rigid fork, vertical motion increased with an increase in incoming velocity. Conclusion: Wheel diameter has a significant influence on the vertical motion of a mountain bike; however, changes of velocity were not affected by wheel size. Wheel diameter on a mountain bike with a rigid front fork has a significant influence on vertical motion while a bike travels along a bumpy track. The larger wheel diameter produced greater vertical motion. -
Comparison of power output demands for a top-10 ranking between Tour de France and Vuelta a España
Background: Grand Tours (GT) are extreme endurance cycling events with about 3500 km covered in twenty-one stages during three weeks. Using the heart rate measurement, Lucia et al. (Lucia et al., 2003: Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 35(5), 872-878) showed that the total exercise load (volume x intensity) do not differ between the Tour de France (TdF) and Vuelta a Espana (VaE). Since powermeters are daily used by the professional cyclists, there are some studies which investigated power output (PO) during Grand Tour but none has made PO measurement on a top-10 overall ranking cyclist to compare PO in different intensity zones in TdF and VaE.Purpose: The purpose of this study was to compare the physical performance level between TdF and VaE of a top-10 overall ranking cyclist from PO measurements. Methods: The PO data of a cyclist (23 yrs, 180 cm and 65 kg) who finished in the top-10 overall ranking in TdF 2012 (10th) and VaE 2013 (7th) were analysed to evaluate the physical performance level on each race from 1/ the determination of the Record Power Profile (RPP) of TdF and VaE according to the methodology of Pinot and Grappe (Pinot & Grappe, 2011: International Journal of Sports medicine, 32, 839-844) and 2/ the comparison of the maximal efforts in the five exercise intensity zones defined from the RPP.Results: Figure 1 shows the RPP of the cyclist in TdF and VaE. The performance level in the low part of the severe intensity (zone 3) is similar in the two GT (Table 1). In the heavy intensity (zone 2) there is a slight increase (+1.6%) of the performance level in VaE. The level of performance in moderate intensity (zone 1) and in force-velocity (zone 5) are higher in the Tdf (5.1% and 2.6%, respectively) while it’s the opposite in the high part of severe intensity (zone 4) (+6.9% in VaE).Discussion: This study shows that the maximal efforts made between 5 and 60 min both in the TdF and VaE are very close in a top-10 overall ranking. This result means that the cyclist performed in the heavy and in the low part of the severe intensity zones at the same physical level of performance in the two GT although the characteristics of the roads were different (11 summit finishes & 36 km of individual time trials (ITT) in VaE 2013 vs. 4 summit finishes in Tdf 2012, longer stages (+8%) and 100 km of ITT). The results are in accordance with the specificity of the efforts performed between the maximal aerobic power (MAP) and the anaerobic threshold to get a ranking in the top 10 in a GT. Indeed, the general classification in a GT usually plays in mountain ascents and during ITT. The shorter and steeper finish ascents in VaE could explain why the record PO between 30 sec and 5 min were higher than in TdF. The higher level of performance in TdF in moderate intensity is due to a long breakaway of the cyclist performed to go win a stage. Conclusion: To achieve an overall ranking top 10 in a GT, the level of performance in the heavy and in the low part of the severe intensity zones is essential. To get there, the levels of both MAP and anaerobic threshold must be the highest possible. -
Acute cycling sport causes upper respiratory tract infections and lung function loss among male recreational cyclists of different age groups
Background: Prolonged high intensity aerobic activity could lead to suppression of mucosal immune proteins like salivary IgA subclass, lactoferrin causing temporary immune suppressed state which may lead to Upper respiratory tract infections and loss in lung function. Purpose: This study examined the effect of acute cycling sport on the status of URTI and Forced Expiratory Volume of first second (FEV1) among the recreational cyclists, who participated in their first ever acute cycling sport of minimum 140 kms in a competitive set up. Methods: Seventy five first time recreational volunteer cyclists in four age groups were analysed on their URTI and FEV1. Wisconsin Upper Respiratory Symptom Survey (WURSS-21) score was used to analyse the URTI and Digital spirometer was used to record the FEV1. Fifteen volunteers for each age group were analysed and results compared. Age groups studied were 20-25yrs, 25-30, 30-35 and 35 above. Pre event and post event URTI and FEV1 were analysed with Analysis of Covariance (ANCOVA). Highest scores of the URTI and FEV1 within the first seven days of post event were included. Results: Covariance analysis (P<.05) indicated, for both URTI and FEV1 the four groups showed significant difference among themselves on their post event status. Adjusted post event URTI means were 62.92 (20-25 yrs), 55.03 (25-30), 79.56 (30-35) and 84.63(35 above). Tukey HSD post hoc comparison indicated that 35+ group experienced significant increases (P<.05) in their URTI symptoms, though the 30-35 group also experienced considerable increase in URTI symptoms. Adjusted post event FEV1 were 79.63, 81.51, 78.39 and 78 for the four groups and the Tukey post hoc analysis (P<.05) indicated that there were significant decrements in the FEV1 of both 30-35 and 35+ groups. Discussion: Peripheral airway change and hyper reactivity due to immunologic and inflammatory cell facilitation could be the reason for temporary bronchoconstriction leading to latent loss in lung function. Conclusions: Recreational cyclists of plus 35 years are vulnerable group with respect to the upper respiratory tract infections and loss of lung function considerably due to acute long distance cycling events. -
Three ways of assessing the forces at the knee and ankle while cycling
The analysis of the biomechanics of the leg while cycling is based on assumptions that make the calculations easier or faster. Most of the models and optimisations based on the dynamic chains introduced by Gonzalez & Hull (Hull & Gonzalez, 1988: J. Biomechanics, 21(10), 839-849) and by Papadopoulos (Papadopoulos, 1987: Biomechanics in Sport, 6, 83-92) with 5 and 4 links respectively share many of these assumptions. For instance, a fixed or no distance from the seat to the centre of rotation of the hip, a constant length of the segments of the leg (thigh, shank and foot) or a constant angular speed of the crank. Previous work (Rios Soltero et al., 2014: Procedia Engineering, in press) has shown that these assumptions may have an influence on the inertial forces of the system. The present study shows that the generalised forces at the knee and ankle would also be different. As it was done before (Rios Soltero et al, 2014), the dynamic chain consisted of three leg segments (thigh, shank and foot), a crank and a grounding element. Also, three motion models were used to calculate the forces at each instant of the pedalling cycle in the sagittal plane at the knee and ankle (Figure 1.a). Here, the analysis was based on the force data at the pedal reported by Boyd et al. (1996, J. Biomechanics, 29(8), 1105-1110), and the motion capture of markers located at the leg and pedal from Rios Soltero et al. (2014). The crank speed was calculated from the pedal marker. To get the orientation angle of each segment, the first two models used a linear regression of their markers. One of them (Inters; intersections method) intersected each line of contiguous segments (thigh with shank and seat-tube, shank with foot and thigh, foot with crank and shank, and crank with seat-tube and foot) to create a dynamic chain at each instant. This allowed a change in length of the segments and the motion of the hip. The second method (Proj; projections method) only uses the orientation of the linear regression for each segment, while their lengths were constant as measured directly from the person. In this way, neither the hip nor the length of the segments were fixed. The third method (Kin; kinematics method) reproduced the assumptions of other studies: a hip fixed at the seat and unvarying length of the leg segments. The length of the leg segments was calculated according to anatomical tables (Winter, 2004: Biomechanics and motor control of human movement (3d ed.). John Wiley & Sons). To calculate the position of the thigh at each instant, an 8th-degree polynomial regression was calculated between the angle of the crank and that of the thigh. In all cases, the centre of mass and mass-moment of inertia of the thigh and shank were calculated using an analytical equation based on the geometry proposed by Durkin Teague et al. (2005: J. Biomechanical Engineering 127, 455-464) and Durkin and Dowling (2006: Annals of Biomedical Engineering 34, pp. 1483-1493). An elliptical frustum was used for the foot. The results of the analysis show a slight difference in the moments at the ankle and the knee for the first half of the cycle (Figure 1.b). The maximum absolute difference in the case of the knee is 15.4 N·m (between Inters and Kin) which is around 13% of the values' range. As for the ankle, it is 7.79 N·m (between Inters and Proj) with a 19% of the values' range. It is clear that there is no qualitative difference between the models. However, further analysis is needed to determine if there is a significant effect. -
The influence of aerobic fitness on the oxygen uptake kinetics of trained cyclists
Introduction: The oxygen uptake kinetics of cyclists with O2max values associated with Elite standards has not been investigated. A hypothesis was tested stating that trained cyclists have faster oxygen uptake responses as aerobic fitness increases.
Methods: Participants (n = 16, combined group) completed a series of square wave 6-min exercises at moderate (80% LT), heavy (50%∆ between the power at LT and O2max), and severe (power at O2max) intensities. The O2 response after the onset of exercise was described by a double exponential model. Participants were further assigned to a high fitness (HF, n = 8) group ( O2max 65 ± 4.7 ml min-1 kg-1) and a moderate fitness (MF, n = 8) group ( O2max 55.1 ± 4.8 ml min-1 kg-1).
Results: Results showed a significant slowing of phase II response time (t) above the LT (P < 0.05), and a reduction in gain (G) during severe intensity exercise (P < 0.05). During heavy intensity exercise, t was moderately correlated with O2max (r = -0.64, P < 0.1), and significant differences (P < 0.05) occurred between HF and MF groups. A significant difference also occurred in G between HF and MF groups (F = 5.6, P < 0.05) despite no change in the slow component.
Conclusion: It was concluded that during heavy intensity exercise, the speed of oxygen uptake kinetics continued to improve with increasing aerobic fitness. The mechanism responsible was hypothesised to be related to the percentage of type I muscle fibres. -
Effect of hand cooling on body temperature, cardiovascular and perceptual responses during recumbent cycling in a hot environment
Exercise in hot environments increases body temperature and challenges the function of cardiovascular, metabolic and thermoregulatory systems. Elevated body temperature as a consequence of prolonged and/or intense exercise impairs athletic performance and increases the risk of heat illness and serious medical conditions. Pre-exercise cooling techniques have been used to lower body temperature and increase heat storage capacity during exercise. Head, neck and wrist cooling have also been employed to reduce physiological strain in hot environments. Although the majority of these methods have proven useful, some are impractical for use during exercise when heat strain is most pronounced. Hand cooling during exercise has the potential to alleviate these impracticalities and attenuate increases in body temperature due to the hands large surface to mass ratio, low metabolic heat production, large blood supply and rapid cooling rates. Reductions in body temperature after bouts of exercise and improvements in exercise performance have been observed using various hand cooling protocols. However, the effectiveness of hand cooling during exercise in a hot environment and the mechanisms of action are unclear. The purpose of the study was to quantify physiological and perceptual responses to hand immersion in water during recumbent cycling in a hot environment. In a randomised control design 7 well-trained males (body mass 79.8 s 6.3 kg; stature 182 s 5 cm; age 23 s 3 years; recumbent cycling V ̇O2peak 41 s 5 ml•kg-1•min-1) who were naïve to the study aims provided informed consent to participate in 3 trials. Participants immersed their hands in 8, 14 and 34°C water whilst cycling at an intensity (W) equivalent to 50% V ̇O2peak for 60 min in an environmental chamber maintained at 35°C 50% relative humidity. Intestinal and 4-site mean skin temperature and heart rate were monitored continuously and mean-averaged over 5 minute intervals. Rating of perceived exertion and thermal strain were assessed every 5 minutes. Data was assessed for normality and homogeneity of variance. The likelihood (% chance) of between group differences was assessed using a magnitude-based approach, Cohen's standardised difference score (d = 0.20 small, 0.5 moderate and 0.8 large effect) and 90% confidence intervals for [d]. Change in intestinal temperature was likely (84%) less in 8°C; 0.43 s 0.16°C versus 34°C; 0.55 s 0.16°C after 15 min; d = 0.73 [-0.19 to 1.65] and very likely (98%) less in 8°C; 0.78 s 0.28°C versus 34°C; 1.22 s 0.16°C after 40 min d = 1.36 [0.47 to 2.25]. Change in mean skin temperature was likely (87%) less in 8°C; -0.05 s 0.39°C versus 34°C; 0.31 s 0.46°C; d = 0.81 [0.09 to 1.71] after 5 min, very likely (98%) less after 15 min; -0.09 s 0.72°C versus 0.77 s 0.30°C; d = 1.24 [0.45 to 2.03] and onwards to cessation of exercise. Percentage of peak heart rate was likely (94%) lower in 8°C; 87 s 4% versus 34°C; 90 s 5% from 25 min onwards; d = 0.69 [0.18 to 1.20]. After 5 min of exercise rating of perceived exertion was likely (77%) lower in 8°C; 12.6 s 1.0 versus 34°C 13.4 s 1.7; d = 0.61 [-0.36 to 1.57] but was likely similar from 25 min onwards. Perception of thermal strain was likely (92%) lower in 8°C; 6.5 s 0.5 versus 34°C; 7.2 s 0.4 after 5 min exercise; d = 0.81 [0.09 to 1.71] and was almost certainly (>99%) lower; 7.3 s 0.7 versus 8.0 s 0.7 for the remainder of the trial; d = 1.21 [0.65 to 1.77]. Similar beneficial effects were observed for 14°C versus 34°C immersion but the magnitude of the effects was smaller than 8°C immersion. Small-to-moderate differences were observed between 8°C and 14°C immersion. The findings suggest that hand cooling during fixed moderate-intensity cycling in a hot environment has the potential to alleviate increases in body temperature, cardiovascular demand and perceptions of exertion and thermal strain. Greatest effects were observed when the hands were immersed in 8°C water compared with 14°C. Augmented heat loss at the palm-water surface might enable cooler blood to return to core and shell regions; increasing the thermal gradient between active tissue and blood thus improving internal heat transfer, maintaining a wide core to skin temperature gradient and reducing heat storage. Limiting the increase in body temperature might have lowered cardiovascular demands by reducing the requirement for cutaneous vasodilation thus lowering physiological strain. These combined effects are manifested in lowered perceptions of exertion and thermal strain. The findings from this study suggest that endurance exercise in hot environments might be improved by hand cooling and future research should investigate its effectiveness during cycling and running performance. -
Optimisation of cycling training
Introduction: Training is fundamental to improving athletic performance, and progressive training schedules are commonly adopted. However, the quantification and optimisation of a progressive training schedule in order to “peak” at a particular competition is an open problem. This paper explores this problem through the use of a mathematical model of training that is well known, but that has proved difficult to implement in practice.
Purpose: To investigate a methodology to quantify the effect of training on potential performance for an individual rider based on data collected in the field and to describe how the quantification of training can be used to determine an optimal training schedule.
Methods: The methodology uses power output, collected using a power meter, and heart-rate, collected using a heart-rate monitor, of all sessions (training or racing) in a rider’s history. The power output developed in a session at time t is related to the heart-rate and power output in sessions up to time t using a statistical model in which performance output depends on training input. The training input measure: relates to all sessions conducted to date; is called the accumulated training effect (ATE); and is based on the Banister model (Banister et al., 1975: Australian Journal of Sports Medicine 7, 57-61). The measure has a number of unknown parameters that require estimation for a particular rider. The performance output measure: relates to a particular session; and is notionally that heart-rate required during a session to maintain a high percentile of power output. The resulting statistical model of training and performance is fitted to the power output/heart-rate histories of 11 competitive cyclists.
Results: Estimates of model parameters are obtained for the eleven riders. The extent to which performance is statistically, significantly related to training depends on the rider and the exact specification of the performance and training measures. Figure 1 shows for example the performance (hp75: the heart-rate required by a rider during a session to maintain his/her long-term upper quartile power output) and training measures over the training period for a particular rider. Discussion: If performance is statistically, significantly related to training and thus the training measure parameters are known, then in principle training can be optimised (with respect to the model). However, many issues remain: considerable noise in the heart-rate, power output relationship means that model parameters are not well estimated; refinement of the model is required in relation to cardio-vascular drift; training data must be complete (no missing sessions) and this is not always the case or even known; the appropriate value for the power output percentile of the performance measure is not obvious.
Conclusion: Preliminary results indicate some success in quantifying the Banister model of training and performance for individual riders using power output and heart-rate data collected in the field. -
The effects of different strength training regimes on cycling performance
Background: There is conflicting literature on the effect of strength training on road cycling performance, with the most recent literature showing a positive effect with maximal strength training (Rønnestad & Mujika, 2013: Scan J Med Sci Sports, Aug 5. doi: 10.1111/sms.12104). Most of these studies are flawed in that they compare strength training added to an endurance program with only endurance training, while many elite cyclists already use some sort of strength training in their program, mainly sub maximal or explosive resistance training. Purpose: To determine if maximal strength training is superior to sub maximal strength training, we compared the effects of maximal and sub maximal strength training programs on cycling performance in young elite cyclists, while keeping the number of strength training sessions equal.
Methods: The programs consisted of maximal (front squats, squat jumps, 1 arm dumbbell press, box steps, Romanian deadlifts (week 1-4) and squat (90o), box jumps, 1 arm dumbbell pull, one legged squat and deadlift from knee height (week 6-9), 3-5 sets of 3-6 RM) or sub maximal strength training (half squat, squat jumps, 1 arm dumbbell press, leg press (1 leg), Romanian deadlift (week 1-4) and half squat, hip flexion, bent over row, box steps and calf lifting (week 6-9), 3 sets of 8-12 repetitions). Strength training was performed twice a week and was concurrent to cycling endurance training, which was kept similar for both groups, though individualized. Seventeen male cyclists were assessed for mean maximal power output over 5, 15, 30, 60, 240 and 600 s (Quad et al., 2010: Int J Sports Med, 31(6), 397-401) 3-7 days before and after the first and last strength training. Precision of the estimate was used to determine probabilities of practical significance.
Results: Between-group differences for all cycling tests were found unclear, except at 15 s mean maximal power (4.2%; ±3.5% likely) and at 30 s mean maximal power (7.6%; ±5.6% very likely), where the maximal strength group performed worse (Table 1).
Discussion: Maximal strength training was not superior over sub maximal strength training in these elite cyclists. A possible explanation for the discrepancy with recent studies is that the participants in our study were already used to strength training, while in these recent studies the participants had no experience with strength training and the strength training was added to their cycling training, increasing the amount of training time for the experimental groups (e.g. Rønnestad et al., 2010: Eur J Appl Physiol, 110(6), 1269-1282). Coming from relative rest, the increase in endurance performance in both groups show that both training programs are effective, although the maximal training group decreased their 15 s and 30 s mean maximal power output, possibly due to detraining of the anaerobic glycolytic pathways, while the sub max group did maintain these pathways through the multiple efforts with short recovery.
Conclusion: No difference was found in increase in endurance performance in elite cyclists using maximal or sub maximal strength training, suggesting that sub maximal strength training is sufficient and effective for road cycling performance. -
Differences in power output between national and club level cyclists during a new variable power cycling test
Background: The demands of road cycling comprise rapid and frequent variations in power output. Recently, our lab developed a 60 min variable power cycling performance test (VCT) and established its reliability for measuring power output in trained male cyclists (Sharma et al, 2014: Reliability and validity of a new variable power performance test in road cyclists, 6th Exercise and Sport Science Australia Conference, Adelaide, Australia). The VCT was modelled on data from elite men’s road racing (Ebert et al., 2006: International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 1, p. 324-335) and included substantial variation in power output.
Purpose: The purpose of this investigation was to determine the differences in power output between national and club level cyclists during a new test of variable cycling performance (VCT).
Methods: Nine national (N) level (mean ± s; age: 24 ± 5.2 years; mass: 71 ± 8.5 kg; peak power output: 5.3 ± 0.4 W/kg) and fourteen club (C) level cyclists (mean ± s; age: 33 ± 6.7 years; mass: 79 ± 5.5 kg; peak power output 4.6 ± 0.4 W/kg) each completed an incremental exercise test (for determination of peak power output) and a VCT (plus familiarisation). The VCT consisted of 10 x 6 min “laps”, with each lap consisting of self-paced periods where the participant were instructed to cycle at their perceived “recovery”, “hard” or “sprint” pace (figure 1). Power output was monitored continuously during the VCT.
Results: Mean power output (W/kg) for the VCT was significantly greater in N than C (mean ± s; 3.53 ± 0.24 vs. 3.18 ± 0.17; p = 0.001). Power output at each lap (figure 2) was also significantly higher in SN (p < 0.01). Relative mean power (% PPO) for sprint efforts was greater in N (mean ± s; 185 ± 29% vs. 171 ± 29%; mean difference; 14.3%, 95% CI [12.9, 15.7]) and also for “hard” efforts (mean ± s; 143 ± 13% vs. 132 ± 19%; mean difference 10.8%, 95% CI [9.7, 11.9]).
Discussion: National level cyclists were able to sustain a greater overall power output throughout the trial, as well as during sprints and hard efforts. Interestingly, the national cyclists adopted a parabolic pacing strategy, compared to the largely even pacing of the club cyclists (figure 2). Whilst both groups were able to increase power output in the latter laps, the national cyclists did so by a greater amount (figure 2). Furthermore, during the sprint and “hard” effort sections of the VCT, the national cyclists were consistently higher in power output, which may suggest an improved lactate tolerance (Coleman, 2013. In Hopker and Jobson (Eds.), Performance cycling: the science of success, 13-32. London: Bloomsbury). Thus, muscle acid/base properties associated with fatigue resistance may be highly relevant to performance during variable power cycling, including muscle buffering capacity (Chicharro et al., 2000: British Journal of Sports Medicine, 34, p. 450-455) and clearance of lactate and other metabolites (Coleman, 2013).
Conclusion: These findings suggest the VCT is a valid test of stochastic performance in trained cyclists. -
The effect of beetroot juice dosage on high intensity intermittent cycling performance
Background: Resynthesis of creatine phosphate (PCr) and intramuscular pH, which influences glycolytic rate, are dependent on skeletal muscle blood flow (Sahlin et al., 1979: Scandinavian Journal of Clinical and Laboratory Investigation 39(6):551-8; Sutton et al., 1981: Clinical Science 61(3):331-8). Skeletal muscle blood flow during exercise has been shown to be enhanced following supplementation with nitrate-rich beetroot juice (BJ) through a nitrate-nitrite-nitric oxide-mediated mechanism (Ferguson et al., 2013: Journal of Physiology 591(Pt 2):547-57).
Purpose: The purpose of this study was to determine if acute supplementation with BJ enhanced subsequent high intensity intermittent cycling performance and to investigate if performance gains could be influenced by varying BJ dosage.
Methods: In a randomised control trial with a repeated-measures crossover design, 2 hours after consumption of low dose (250ml), high dose (500ml) of a commercially available BJ or nothing, 8 active young males (24 ± 8.5yrs) completed three 30s Wingate anaerobic tests (WAnT) on a Monark 894E interspersed with 3 minutes active cycling recovery at low intensity. The three trials were separated by a 7-day washout period for each participant. Peak power (PP), mean power (MP) and fatigue index (FI) were recorded for each WAnT and were compared using a two-way repeated measures ANOVA.
Results: MP declined successively in the second and third WAnT in each trial (p<0.05), however no changes were observed in PP or FI in any trial. No significant differences in MP, PP or FI at any time point were observed across the three treatment arms.
Discussion: The maintenance of PP across successive WAnT indicates resynthesis of PCr during recovery periods, but the decline of MP possibly suggests a progressive decline in total PCr availability and/or a decline in intramuscular pH at each stage. Lack of a supplementation effect on measures of anaerobic power suggests BJ neither expedites PCr resynthesis nor restores intramuscular pH through either a skeletal muscle blood flow or other mechanism.
Conclusion: Acute supplementation with BJ has no beneficial effect, even with high dosage, on high intensity intermittent cycling performance. -
An investigation of the biomechanical efficacy and clinical effectiveness of patello-femoral taping in elite and experienced cyclists
Background: From high profile events such as the Tour De France and the Olympics, it is noticeable that kinesiology type taping (KTT) is used widely within elite cycling for treatment of knee pain. Taping is a clinical treatment for the over-use/overload pathology of patello-femoral pain (PFP) in elite and experienced cyclists, however it is unknown as to whether it effects any biomechanical change that can be useful in a clinical setting. PFP in cycling is often referred to as cyclists’ knee or anterior knee pain, and has been reported to occur in over 25% of all cyclists. (Callaghan, 2005: Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies, 9, 226-236). Some cyclists are pre-disposed to excessive knee movement during the pedal stroke (Bailey et al, 2003: Journal of Sports Sciences, 21 (2), 649–657), and consequently at different power levels and cadences this movement may affect biomechanical factors at the knee. An increased understanding of taping and the biomechanics of the knee during cycling could greatly improve the active prevention and treatment of overuse problems during cycling.
Purpose: To determine and evaluate any biomechanical changes around the knee in elite and experienced cyclists both with and without knee pain, using established taping techniques at varying powers.Methods: 12 asymptomatic participants and 8 symptomatic participants conducted three separate tests at three powers (100w, 200w & 300w) on a static trainer using a Powertap™ rear wheel and their own bike (fig 1). The study was conducted under three randomised conditions a) no tape, b) placebo tape, c) Kinesiology type tape (fig 2). Kinematic data were collected using a 10-camera Qualysis motion analysis system (fig 3). Reflective markers were placed on the foot, shank, thigh and pelvis using the CAST technique (fig 4). Visual 3D software was used to export to SPSS (fig 5&6).
Results: Measurements and statistical analysis were undertaken in the knee, hip and ankle/foot. Mixed methods and repeated-measures two-way ANOVA test were performed together with posthoc Pairwise comparison with Bonferroni adjustment to examine differences in three-dimensional movement under the different conditions/powers. Results were presented in kinematic pattern, range of motion (ROM) and statistical differences (fig 6,7,8) for comprehensive clinical application and relevance. Alongside this, a new approach was investigated to measure the knee ‘in relation to’ both the hip/pelvis and ankle/foot (fig 6). Results indicate statistical differences between conditions and powers (Fig 7) however at this stage their clinical significance has not yet been fully determined. The lower powers indicate instability and the higher powers indicate changes both distally and proximally to the knee. There appears to be a separation in the differences between cyclists tested with and without pain, however this does not necessarily indicate that KTT produces this in isolation. The differences vary across conditions and powers.
Discussion: It is noticeable that the knee is not the only implicated joint in cycling related knee pain and taping. In fact all the recent evidence in this area indicate that distal and proximal to the knee are key factors (Powers et al, 2013: Journal Orthop Sports Physical Therapy. 42 (6), A1-54). In line with this evidence both the hip/pelvis and foot indicate changes that may be relevant to clinical application of taping with cyclists. It remains possible that there is a link between these movement patterns and cycling related knee pain however further work is required to fully determine this. The answer to the question does tape change what is happening at the knee is yes. Does it do different things with those with pain? Again, yes, to some degree. That said however, the clinical relevance requires a deeper analysis of the kinematic pattern data alongside the range of motion. The work undertaken to date in this project indicates the complexities of both human movement and the variables of a highly repetitive sport. The statistical change in the sagittal plane may indicate a muscular effect from taping however there were also changes by neutral taping which is interesting considering the specific nature of the KTT technique. Perhaps this specificity is not as critical as often indicated by manufacturers?
Conclusion: Cycling related knee pain is a complex and under-researched area and we understand little of its treatment efficacy and effectiveness. Further work is required to investigate the relationship within the kinematics measured in this study. Distal and proximal effects are broadly in line with gait-based evidence. For clinical significance the statistics, kinematic patterns and ROM need to be considered as a whole. Specific application of tape technique may not be critical to achieve a measurable change. -
An online survey using social media investigating the use of kinesiology type tape and McConnell type tape with clinicians who treat cycling related knee pain
Background: The Tour de France will undoubtedly showcase various cycling related injuries in its Yorkshire opening stages in 2014. Patello-Femoral Pain (PFP) is responsible for over 25% of all road cycling injuries and over 65% of injuries in the lower limb (Callaghan, 2005: Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies, 9, 226-236). Alongside trauma related pain it remains the main injury affecting experienced and elite cyclists and is commonly treated using taping (broadly categorised into McConnell and kinesiology type tape - KTT). To date it is unknown as to the extent and rationale behind the use of tape in cycling related knee pain.
Purpose: To determine clinicians’ current use of taping in elite and experienced cyclists with cycling related knee pain in order to inform a 3D motion analysis study into current taping techniques. To date very little work has been undertaken in this area and although it is presumed that taping is used extensively throughout cycling, it is unknown as to how much it is actually used and the rationale behind its use.
Methods: An online survey (Survey Monkey™) determined current taping techniques used by clinicians treating elite and experienced cyclists. A preferred taping application was determined and reported from a choice of 4 (fig 1). Data were collected from clinicians (n=30), identified as having an area of special clinical interest in cycling related knee pain within the target group. Recruitment was predominantly through the social network Twitter™. Data collected included; treatment methods, clinical taping usage, specific applications, perceived effectiveness of treatment, clinical rationale, formal training, clinical importance and outcome measures.
Results: The data collected indicated a clear preference from clinicians for the use of KTT (figure 2) at >80%. 59% of clinicians used taping to manage pain, 46% for re-aligning patella, and 29% for activation of musculature, (figure 3). Clinicians preferred to initially apply tape, then test in-situ before re-applying (74%) and adapt to each cyclist (87%) - (figure 4). Reported outcome objectives were predominately pain management and biomechanical changes. When asked to score the effects of clinical taping, participants felt that pain; biomechanical changes and proprioception were effective to ‘some degree’ (figure 5). Proprioception was considered very influential by over 50% (figure 5). Reasons for use that scored highly were clinical effectiveness, ease of use and longevity (figure 6). Rating of efficacy and effectiveness scored high in ‘success of outcome’, ‘repeatability & reliability’, and ‘comfort’ (figure 7). >50% felt that placebo had some effect (figure 5).
Discussion: KTT is clearly the tape of choice in cycling today. This is in contrast to the use of McConnell type tape in traditional physical therapy setting. There was considerable variability in clinician’s reasoning for taping use, reflecting gaps in the current knowledge base. Its clinical adaptation usage is in line with previous work by McConnell even though its longevity and comfort appears to separate its practice in cycling. The reported perception of placebo effect from KTT tape is an intriguing adjunct to the findings and should be considered in future research designs for effectiveness using this type of tape. This (placebo effect) was specified as a separate effect from that of proprioception however, which scored highly as a clinical effect. Notably, proprioception in cycling has not been effectively measured to date. Interestingly, clinicians felt it was an effect to some degree (fig 5) whilst also scoring it as not at all important clinically (Figure 7). The use of social media to recruit participants establishes a new and innovative approach to recruitment. This can be seen as timely due to its prevalence in today’s society and increased use amongst clinicians globally for both networking and evidence based practice debate and knowledge transfer.
Conclusions. KTT appears the preferred application in cycling related knee pain. The data provide a clear rationale for the testing of specific taping techniques and indicate how clinicians are currently using taping in the treatment of cycling related knee pain. These results give a clear focus for a follow up study, which would aim to determine the biomechanical efficacy and clinical effectiveness of KTT. This work would determine any biomechanical changes in the PFJ during cycling as well as looking at any effects from neutral and no tape. In addition, a focus on pain and placebo would be interesting outcome measures of future work. -
Wearable multi-sensor system for embedded body position and motion analysis during cycling
Purpose: The purpose of this study was to validate the AREM system in laboratory conditions. AREM is an embedded electronic system for motion tracking and movement analysis, based on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (MEMS) sensors and a reconfigurable hardware/software electronic architecture including FPGA + PSoC embedded boards for real time acquisition and signal processing.
Methods: AREM sensors were installed on cyclist before performing on a test in which other measurements were made to analyse efficiency of standing position. The position of cyclists during whole test was measured by both AREM and a Kinematic Arm and verified by video systems. The protocol included 13 elite participants on a motorised treadmill with their own bike during which they rode in a randomized order seated vs. standing positions with several slopes (5, 7.5 and 10%) and intensities (3.8, 4.2 and 4.6 W.kg-1). GE was calculated for each condition using the ratio of power output (PO) measured with a Powertap G3 hub (CycleOps, Madison, USA) and the oxygen uptake (VO2) measured with a portable gas analyzer (Metamax 3B, Cortex, Leipzig, Germany).
Results & Discussion: The synchronised data of 8 inertial sensors was retrieved and combined to obtain joint positions of shoulders (2), waist (3), middle and lower trunk (2) on cyclist. 1 sensor was installed under the saddle of the bike. The position data was compared between the two systems, and result on validation of AREM for 3-axis displacements (up to 40cm on X axis). We also compared the accelerations (+/- 2 m.s-2 seated to +/- 6 m.s-2 in standing position, errors up to 10% between both systems), power and energies for each cyclist during test steps (kinetic energies variation from 1.1 J/Kg to 3 J/Kg in a pedal stroke). Moreover, the acceleration and orientation data on cyclist and bike revealed different approaches on effort management during the test, and were compared to videos to obtain sensors data according to different “standing position” techniques. This data is an interesting indicator of the cyclist fatigue during a test, and is being crossed with PO and VO2 data.
Conclusion: The validation of AREM system offers the possibility to extend our measures on real cycling locomotion in outdoor conditions, replacing the kinematic arm with AREM.Despite the 3D movement analysis of the cyclist on a standard protocol, first results suggest a position adjustment according to the technique of each cyclist, but also an impact of the mechanical response of the system tires-bike frame. The main perspective of these works is to include the Structure Health Monitoring analysis (SHM) on bike and to synchronise it with the cyclist activity and motion analysis during outdoor training. With both data, we expect to develop a reliable monitoring and optimisation system of the bike-cyclist couple in different course conditions. -
Development of a multi-directional rating test method for bicycle frame stiffness
The methods for determining the bicycle frame stiffness exist in many forms. Because the stiffness measuring method is not standardized, each bicycle magazine or bicycle constructer uses his own test configuration. This leads to a wide variety of setups; they differ in many aspects such as applied load, boundary conditions and frame deflection measurement. To clarify some shortcomings in frame testing, a multi-directional rating test method for bicycle frame stiffness has been developed. The proposed test rig design considers different aspects that should be taken into account when measuring the bicycle frame stiffness.At first, it is important to eliminate perturbing side effects that influence the stiffness value of the bicycle frame. FE analysis revealed that using ‘very stiff’ boundary conditions to constrain certain degrees of freedom should be handled with the utmost caution. Using these non-rigid boundary conditions affects the bicycle frame deflection significantly. Therefore, prior to stiffness testing, the contribution of the test rig compliance should be estimated. It is advised to limit its estimated influence below 2 %. Hysteresis effects due to stick-slip and friction are avoided by omitting fixed boundary conditions and eliminating the friction force when using a pulley mechanism; if not errors up to 11 % are observed. It is recommended to use a rolling contact to constrain translation motion and to measure the force acting on the frame without other mechanisms between the force sensor and the bicycle frame. Another issue is the effect of the head tube bearing type and the preloading torque. The industrial bearings reduce the frame stiffness up to 19 % when comparing with steel bearing replicas. It is the operator’s decision to test bicycle frames with or without industrial bearings for stiffness measurements. Though, steel bearings are advised for mutual frame comparison since this avoids discussion about the differences among industrial bearings. The overall accuracy of the test result is expressed as percentage deviation on the 95 % confidence interval and includes both the influence of the operator and the sensors. To detect small changes between results from different frames, a percentage value of 2 % or less is desired.The selection of stiffness configurations is based on the major load components acting at the head tube, the bottom bracket and the rear-dropout. The bracket- and torsion stiffness are replaced with a specific classification of the test setup. The directional frame stiffness is as such assessed for individual load cases: (i) the in-plane vertical and horizontal stiffness of the bottom-bracket and rear-dropout, (ii) the transversal or out-of-plane stiffness of the bottom bracket and (iii) the torsion stiffness with or without the contribution of the rear-triangle of the bicycle frame. As such is detailed information available for the bicycle constructor to modify the design and for the cyclist when comparing the stiffness characteristics of different frame types. -
Field tests with an instrumented bicycle for comfort measurements
High frame stiffness is one of the most important parameters a racing bicycle should fulfil, it shows advantages in steering stability and a smaller amount of pedalling power is lost due to frame deflection. On the contrary, increased stiffness may attenuate the shock absorption ability of the frame and consequently leading to lack of comfort for the cyclist. This work proposes the absorbed power and whole-body-vibration (ISO-weighting) analysis to measure comfort during outdoor field tests. Absorbed power is measured in Watt, whole-body-vibration is represented as RMS acceleration. Force- and acceleration sensors are designed and installed onto the bicycle near the contact points of cyclist and bicycle, at the saddle and the handlebar. Force is measured through strain gauge configurations and velocity is obtained from integrating acceleration data. The data acquisition system, which is carried by the cyclist, is able to read and store data from 14 sensors simultaneously. Combining both the sensor design and the data acquisition configuration allows for in-situ measurements during outdoor conditions. Acceleration analysis shows that the saddle vibration amplitude increases with speed, though; raising the cycling speed at cobblestones tends to limit the perceived vibration amplitude at the saddle. It is also observed that the rear wheel acts as a filter for road vibrations. The vibration level decreases significantly when comparing the amplitude at the rear wheel axis and the saddle. It can be concluded that the wheel type and tyre pressure has a major contribution in attenuating road vibrations from cobblestones.When comparing the acceleration –and absorbed power frequency spectrum it is seen that the frequency range shifts considerably. The acceleration signal has its dominant peaks near 20-25 Hz whereas the dominant frequencies in the absorbed power spectrum are concentrated in the range below 20 Hz. This could possibly shed another light on analysing human comfort when the absorbed-power method is used instead of acceleration data only. With the absorbed power method, it is also possible to measure accurately the effect of the cyclist’s position on comfort perception. E.g. if the cyclist applies less handlebar grip force, this will generate higher acceleration amplitudes, though the contact force will decrease. Consequently, the whole-body-vibration analysis results in less comfort because of increased acceleration, whereas the absorbed power value shows a lower magnitude because both force and acceleration are taken into account. Hence, the absorbed power analysis is a better measure for the comfort perception of the cyclist. -
Do core stabilization exercises enhance cycling efficiency?
Background: Core stabilization exercises have been advertised as potential enhancers of endurance and efficiency in cycling. A steady core is said to allow for proper body positioning, preventing unnecessary energy loss and will thus allow for maintaining speed and power for a longer time.Previous studies published on core stabilization training in other sports show mixed results. However, no studies addressing a potential effect on gross cycling efficiency (GE) have been published.
Purpose: The aim of this pilot study was to analyze the possible effect of an eight week core-stability training program on trunk balance and gross cycling efficiency.
Methods: 13 well-trained cyclists were included in an 8 week core-stability training program. The daily program consisted of both static and dynamic versions of the plank, side plank, bird-dog, superman, cycling crunch and pulse up exercises lasting an average of 10 minutes per session.Steady-state oxygen uptake and GE were determined as participants approached RER 1.0 (de Koning et al, 2012: Int J Sports Med, 33, 880–885). Grip-strength and the Y-balance test (Coughlan et al, 2012: J Athl Train, 47, 366–371) were used to measure balance. Training compliance was monitored using an online log. GE and core-stability measurements were performed at baseline and after 8 weeks.
Results: An improvement of gross cycling efficiency could not be found (average at baseline 22.0%; after training 22.5%; p=0.26). Compliance to the program was very good, with an average of 84% (75 – 98%) sessions trained. All participants demonstrated an improvement in postero-lateral reach. Three participants reported an episode of lower back discomforts which they attributed to the superman exercise.
Discussion: Our results did not show an improvement of GE after an 8 week core-stability training program. However, current sample size is small and reported values are very close to the +/- 2% error margin of the spirometry hardware used. In 2 participants, we were unable to accurately determine GE. According to our spirometry readings they were unable to attain a steady state in the second test. However, mentioned participants reported a perceived rate of exertion that was lower than expected at RER 1.0. The reason for this discrepancy is unknown. A possible measurement error can be assessed by measuring blood lactate in future tests.
Conclusion: As competitions can be won or lost in fractions of seconds, improving one’s gross efficiency by means of core-stability training could be beneficial. The results of our current pilot study can be used to power future research in this area. -
A contiguous ramp and all-out exercise test to determine critical power in competitive cyclists
Background: Critical power (CP) represents the highest metabolic rate at which oxygen uptake and blood lactate stabilizes during exercise and is strongly associated with endurance exercise performance. Determination of CP typically requires the completion of two to five constant power tests to exhaustion (TTE). An alternative test involves measurement of mean power during the final 30 s of a single 3-minute all-out cycling test, and this test agrees well with CP (Vanhatalo et al.,2007: Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 39, 548-555). However, the 3-minute all-out test requires a preliminary Ramp test to determine the ergometer settings for the subsequent CP assessment.
Purpose: To quantify the reliability of a single contiguous Ramp and 3-minute All-Out test (RAO), and to appraise validity relative to CP determined from serial TTE tests.
Methods: All participants provided written informed consent prior to participation, tests were separated by 2 – 7 d, and studies by 6 – 12 months. Reliability study: Four male triathletes, six male and one female road cyclist ( 2peak 4.32 ± 0.70 L•min-1) completed two RAO (RAO 1 & 2) cycle ergometer tests (Lode Excalibur Sport, Groningen, The Netherlands). The RAO was a contiguous 5-min warm up at 50 W, a ramp-incremental (30 W•min-1) to exhaustion, and a 3-min all-out exercise test. Exhaustion was defined as a cadence ≤ 50 rpm. The ergometer resistance during the AO phase was defined prior to exercise using: (body mass (kg) x 3.5) / 852. Cadence and duration was withheld during the AO phase. Validity study: Five triathletes and two road cyclists ( 2peak 3.96 ± 0.53 L•min-1) completed the RAO before and after a series of at least four constant power TTE designed to elicit exhaustion between ~ 3-15 min. For TTE tests the asymptote (CP) and curvature constant (W´) of the power-duration relationship were quantified using 2-parameter nonlinear regression models. For RAO tests the estimated CP (ECP) was calculated as the mean power output over the final 30 s of the RAO, and estimated W´ (EW´) was calculated as the power-time integral above ECP during the RAO. Statistics: Data are reported as mean, standard deviation. Data was appraised using a repeated measures general linear model for quantification of bias and typical error (TE). The relationship between protocols was quantified using coefficient of variation (CV).
Results: Reliability study: ECP in RAO1 (289, 38 W) and RAO2 (292, 41 W) were not different (P = 0.24, TE 7 W, mean bias of 4 ± 19 W). ECP between repeats were very strongly related (CV 2%). EW´ in RAO1 (12.6, 3.4 kJ) and RAO2 (12.0, 4.2 kJ) were not different (P = 0.49, TE 2.0 kJ, mean bias of -0.6 ± 5.5 kJ), and were related (CV 13%). Validity study: Durations of TTE ranged from 170 (34) to 861 (202) s. A 5 W (1.8%) standard error was associated with the estimate of CP using the 2-parameter model. ECP (280, 36 W) was not different to CP (279, 34 W; P = 0.95, TE 10 W). Comparisons revealed a mean bias of 1 ± 27 W, (CV 3%). EW´ (17.1, 3.4 kJ) was not different to W´ (15.8, 2.8 kJ; P = 0.461, TE 1.8 kJ, mean bias of -1.35 ± 8.9 kJ), EW´ and W´ were related (CV 14%).
Discussion: The RAO test parameters were sufficiently reliable for use in future studies. Similar to previous studies investigating alternative methods for power-duration curve estimation, the reproducibility of ECP was small (CV 2%), but EW´ was wider (13%). The mean difference between parameter estimates of CP and W´ using the traditional TTE test and single RAO test was negligible. The limits of agreement between the CP estimate derived from a series of maximal constant power TTE tests and the single test RAO protocol were moderately wide (27 W) but similar to previous reports of AO-exercise strategies for CP estimation.
Conclusion: The CP and W´ estimates from a single test were similar to traditional testing methods that require multiple maximal exercise tests. Therefore, the RAO test may simplify CP estimation in competitive cyclists. -
A depth camera-based system for estimating cyclist-bike projected frontal area
A major component of total resistive force in cycling is aerodynamic drag. For speeds greater than ~14 m/s aerodynamic drag accounts for approximately 90% of total resistive force (Debraux et al., 2009: International Journal of Sports Medicine, 30, 266-272). Together with the air density, the coefficient of drag and the velocity of the cyclist-bike, an important determinant of aerodynamic drag is projected frontal area. Several techniques have been used to estimate the projected frontal area of a cyclist-bike, including the weighing of photographs and image digitising (Debraux et al., 2009). These techniques are similar as they involve extracting the cyclist-bike from a two-dimensional (2D) image and using scaling information from a plane of known dimensions. With the weighing photographs method this is done physically using sensitive weighing scales whereas image processing software is used for the image digitising technique. Both techniques require the collection of a calibration plane, involve considerable post-processing and cannot be performed in real time. We have developed a depth camera-based system for estimating cyclist-bike projected frontal area which addresses these issues. The depth camera algorithm works by creating a metrically scaled, three-dimensional point cloud of the cyclist-bike. The point cloud is projected on to a 2D representation of the scene and the area of the point cloud is calculated using a technique similar to ‘voxelization’; points in the cloud occupy spaces in a fine grid – the sum of the occupied grid spaces gives total area. The aim of this study was to investigate the agreement between our new method and the image digitising technique.After institutional ethics approval, eight regular cyclists volunteered to participate and provided written informed consent. Participants wore their normal cycling clothing and their bicycle was mounted on a stationary indoor trainer. The bicycle was positioned against a white background to help with the image digitising method. Participants placed their feet on the pedals and held the cranks parallel to the floor. A digital camera (Canon EOS 400D, 10.1 megapixel) and Kinect depth camera (Microsoft, Redmond, WA, USA) were mounted on tripods at a height of 1.1 m and positioned 5 m and 2.2 m in front of the participant, respectively. Similar to Debraux et al. (2009), participants adopted two positions on the bike: 1. Upright – upright torso with hands close to the stem and 2. Drops Position – hands on the drops. Three repeat captures were performed in each position, with the participant relaxing between each capture. The digitising method was performed as described by Debraux et al. (2009). Agreement between methods was assessed using limits of agreement (LOA - Bland and Altman, 1986: Lancet, 1, 307-310). A two-way repeated measures analysis of variance (method by position) was used to assess the effect of cyclist position on the systematic difference between measurement methods.There was no interaction between cyclist position and measurement method (p = 0.201) indicating that the same effect of cyclist position was observed using both measurement techniques. A significant main effect for cyclist position (p = 0.017) indicated that projected frontal area was smaller with hands on the drops (upright: 0.485 m2, drops: 0.434 m2). There was also a significant main effect for measurement method (p < 0.001) indicating a significantly smaller estimation of projected frontal area using the Kinect (Kinect: 0.416 m2, Image: 0.503 m2). A predominantly systematic difference between methods was also suggested by the LOA analysis (upright: 0.086 ± 0.029 m2, drops: 0.090 ± 0.033 m2).The aim of this study was to assess the agreement between a common method of estimating cyclist-bike frontal area and a new depth camera-based technique. The new technique estimated systematically smaller projected frontal area than the image digitisation method but there was relatively little random variation and the same effect of cyclist position was observed with both techniques. Which technique gives the most accurate estimate of projected frontal area is not clear as the image digitisation technique - to which the new technique was compared - has associated errors e.g. identification of the cyclist-bike outline and out-of-plane errors. However, it was apparent during testing that the depth camera-based system often failed to identify parts of the bike and this is most likely the cause of the difference between techniques. Regardless, the results of this study suggest that the new technique can be used to assess changes in projected frontal area – as the cyclist changes position, for example. Further, the new technique offers the possibility of analysing changes in projected frontal area in real time – there is no requirement for calibration or post-processing. -
Muscular fatigue of the lower limb and subsequent joint angle adaptations during a 16.1km cycling time trial
Background: Effective muscular recruitment during cycling is crucial to optimising performance. As such, much research has examined when muscles are active during the pedal revolution and how muscle co-activation may influence pedalling technique but little evidence associated with the effect of fatigue on lower limb joint angles and its subsequent effect on power output and muscle recruitment. Purpose: Are changes in muscular recruitment patterns and changes in lower limb kinematics detrimental to performance?
Methods: A preliminary case study of a well-trained veteran cyclist (V ̇O"2peak" 49.9 ml . kg-1 . min-1 and PPO of 400W) conducted a 16.1km simulated cycling time trial on a Wattbike Pro at 80% PPO with a cadence of 98 rpm. Bilateral surface EMG were employed using pairs of Ag/AgCl electrodes adhered to both right and left vastus medialis (VM), biceps femoris (BF), tibialis anterior (TA) and gastrocnemius (GM). Intervals of sixty seconds in duration, of 3D kinematic and electromyography (EMG) data were synchronised using a Vicon motion capture system throughout the time trial. Ten consecutive pedal revolutions per 60 s interval were processed for subsequent analysis. Kinematic and EMG data signals were imported into Visual 3D v.5 and Matlab for processing.
Results: There were statistically significant changes (p<0.05) in all kinematic data across nine time points. Fundamental changes occurred between minute 10-12 with a decrease in flexion angle for the left hip (z = -9.56, p<0.05, r = 0.55), and the right hip, (z = -7.67, p<0.05, r = 0.44). The left ankle starts to have a greater planter flexion (z = -9.69, p<0.05, r = 0.56) between minutes 10-12 and this continues to have a significant change between time points for the remainder of the trial. The magnitude of EMG data revealed that there were statistically significant changes (p<0.05) in all muscles across seven time points. Decreases in the magnitude of activation were observed between minutes 8-10 for both the left (z = -9.17, p<0.05, r = 0.53) and right (z = -8.21, p<0.0005, r = 0.48) TA. The frequency domain EMG analysis indicated a trend towards lower frequencies being recorded for the left and right TA and GM with a trend towards higher frequencies being recorded for the left and right VM. Analysis of the Wattbike data indicated that there were statistically significant differences from minutes 1 to 20 between left and right angle to peak force applied to the crank (t(19) = 20.89, p<0.05) with no statistical significance between left and right limb percentage use (95% CI 2.81, 3.31%). Indications showed that there was a higher magnitude of activation for the left leg across all muscles tested and the Wattbike data indicates greater power generation on the left side of the pedal revolution.
Discussion: Based on the results from this study there were decreases in the ankles range of motion (ROM) with increases in hip flexion from minute 10-12 with changes in neuromuscular activity between minutes 8-10 then there were smaller effect changes for the remainder of the time trial. The alterations in the EMG median frequency indicated a trend towards muscular fatigue for TA and GM with increases in neuromuscular activity in both VM’s possibly counteracting fatigue. The ankle’s decrease in ROM may be a product of fatigue associated with the TA and GM but by becoming stiffer it may optimise the foot/pedal interface. Even with these changes in kinematic and EMG data the power output remained constant.
Conclusion: As this was a case study further work in this area needs to be considered in establishing variability in joint angles and how they may be beneficial/detrimental in generating the same level of power output when fatigued. An association of muscular fatigue in cycling and changes to lower limb joint angle variability requires further investigation examining joint coupling patterns, independent pedal power analysis and cross reference to physiological parameters for fatigue to establish strategies that may be beneficial in improving cycling performance. -
The reliability and validity of the 3-minute critical power test
Background: Athletes utilise exercise testing to assist with training design and race strategy. Critical power (CP) is a useful addition to an exercise testing battery as it provides an estimate of the heavy-severe exercise domain boundary (Vanhatalo et al., 2007: Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 39(3), 548-55). Although the benefits of calculating CP are known, the traditional CP test protocol is excessively time consuming. Studies have suggested that CP can be obtained from a single 3-minute bout of ‘all-out’ exercise using the Lode Excalibur Sport cycle ergometer in linear mode (Vanhatalo et al., 2008: Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 40(9), 1693-9). A more recent study (Karsten et al., 2013: International Journal of Sports Medicine, 35(4), 304-9) suggests that the 3-minute test does not provide a valid measure of critical power when using the SRM cycle ergometer in isokinetic mode.
Purpose: To investigate the reliability and validity of the 3-minute critical power test in both isokinetic and linear modes using the Lode Excalibur Sport.
Methods: Six male cyclists (mean ± SD; age 33 ± 7.7 yr, body mass 83.42 ± 9.9 kg, maximum aerobic power (MAP) 343 ± 50 W, V̇O2max 4.38 ± 0.77 L•min-1) gave written informed consent to participate in the study, which was approved by Southampton Solent University’s ethics committee. Each participant took part in 8 trials, each separated by a minimum of 48 hours. The first trial took part in two stages. The first was an incremental step test (100 W start with 25 W increments every 3 minutes) to calculate gas exchange threshold (GET). The second stage was a ramp test (100 W start with 20 W•min-1 increments) to calculate MAP and V̇O2max. During trials 2–4, each participant completed three efforts to exhaustion (80, 100 and 105% MAP). The results from these trials were used to calculate critical power, which included both the 1/time (CP1) and work–time (CP2) critical power models. Traditionally, these models have both been used to calculate CP. The final four trials were used to estimate critical power from two separate 3-minute protocols. Two trials were carried out using the linear mode following the protocol described by Vanhatalo et al. (2008). The two remaining trials were carried out in the isokinetic mode at the participant’s preferred cadence following the protocol described by Karsten et al. (2013). Apart from trial one, all testing sessions were carried out in a randomized order. A repeated measures ANOVA was used to compare CP and End Power (EP) with significance set at p<0.05. Coefficient of variation was used to compare EP-isokinetic and EP-linear between each testing session. For reliability to be seen in sports science testing it has been suggested that a CV of less than 5% is required (Hopkins, 2000: A new view on statistics. Retrieved 31 March 2014, from http://www.sportsci.org/resource/stats).
Results: There was no significant difference between EP-isokinetic and CP1 (+2.6 W, p=0.80) or between EP-isokinetic and CP2 (+5.1 W, p=0.46). There were significant differences between EP-linear and CP1 (+31.5 W, p=0.01) and between EP-linear and CP2 (+39.2 W, p=0.02). Coefficient of variation in EP-isokinetic and EP-linear was 3.35% and 1.15%, respectively. Discussion: To the authors’ knowledge this is the first time that the linear and isokinetic modes have been evaluated in a single cohort. The results suggest that the 3-minute isokinetic test provides a reliable measure of EP and a valid measure of CP. Although the 3-minute linear test seems to provide a reliable measure of EP, these results suggest that it does not provide a valid measure of CP. Therefore, the results from this pilot study do not fully support previous literature (Vanhatalo et al., 2008; Karsten et al., 2013).
Conclusion: This study provides preliminary evidence to suggest that the 3-minute isokinetic testing protocol can be used to estimate the heavy-severe exercise domain boundary. -
Application to cycling of a bioenergetic model: Towards a multi-level biomechanical model for global cyclist performance analysis
Introduction: Models of bioenergetic systems are developed to explain how a biological system behaves while interacting with the environment. Recent attempts in sport science research advocate the evidence-based training prescription and performance assessment and help in translating laboratory-based research into real world practice by the means of bioenergetic models. Such models have been developed for cycling activity for constant work rate or intermittent exercise for a single training session (e.g. critical power CP model and reconstitution of the anaerobic work capacity, (Chidnok et al., 2012, Medicine & Science in Sports and Exercise, 44(5), 966-976)), as well as for describing how the performance capacity changes over time (Clarke & Skiba, 2013: Advances in Physiological Education, 37, 134-152). The model here adopted (Moxnes et. al, 2012, Theoretical Biology and Medical Modelling, 9:29) claims to predict both oxygen consumption (V’O2) and lactate production [La]’ dynamically at a given power output requirement. In this work we model the bioenergetics processes involved in human exercise and recovery for the case of a cyclist in outdoor training.
Purpose: The aim of this study is to validate the model in order to track the dynamic state of the anaerobic sources accordingly with the CP model (Monod & Scherrer, 1965, Ergonomics, 8, 329-338) and thus predicting by means of numerical simulations the athlete’s ability of providing supra-CP power outputs during a training session.
Methods: The symbolic bioenergetic models that include V’O2 and [La]’ has been derived according to the work of Moxnes and colleagues (Moxnes et. al, 2012). First set of model’s parameters are estimated with an optimization approach to best fit laboratory continuously logged data for a road cyclist during a 4 min graded incremental exercise ([La], V’O2, and mechanical power). Moreover a recent database of mechanical power values recorded during training sessions of the same athlete have been used as further parameters of the model (e.g. maximal mean power and critical power CP). Secondly experimental data have been acquired in outdoor condition by the means of a powermeter (Power2Max) for the mechanical power, a portable metabolimeter (K4, Cosmed) for the V’O2, and a portable lactate analyzer (Lactate PRO) for the lactate concentration. The first set of experimental parameters is adopted as a first trial solution of an iterative non-linear optimization algorithm that searches for the solution (an optimal set of parameters) which minimises the difference between simulated and the outdoor measured in dependence of the mechanical power.
Results: The optimization algorithm gave a set of parameters for best fit the outdoor measurements which differs from the parameters estimated from the laboratory test. Particularly the V’O2 response for a square wave high intensity exercise is underestimated during the onset, is well predicted at the steady state (with a mean square error <1%) and lightly overestimated during the offset phase. For which concern [La] the model predicts the lactate concentration with increasing error as the exercise proceeds. Accordingly to the modelling literature (Sokolowski and Banks, 2010: Modeling and simulation fundamentals: theoretical underpinnings and practical domains, New Jersey: Wiley) a verification process has been carried out to determine if the model is an accurate representation of the system. The process highlighted that (a) the differences between real and simulation values (residuals) appear to behave randomly after a normality test; that (b) there is a very large (0.8-0.9) correlation coefficient and explained variance from the correlation analysis of residuals and high goodness of fit after a (c) graphical residual analysis. Discussion: Current simulation model provides useful insights into how power data of training or testing should be interpreted despite the model’s limitations. Main mismatches between theoretical model and experimental data are expected especially when important non-linearities are involved such as abrupt changes in mechanical power output requests, transient responses in general, extreme oxygen consumption or lactate concentrations values. A detailed analysis and of model capabilities and possible improvement will be presented.
Conclusion: The current study investigated a mathematical model for the kinetics of aerobic and anaerobic power during a training session at varying intensity. Applying this model for estimating the anaerobic source depletion and the aerobic source utilization over the time and individualize it for different athletes in outdoor conditions is a challenging and interesting task. Starting from this bioenergetic model application, it is reasonable to cautiously conclude that biomechanical modelling can be specifically adopted while trying to predict the response of an athlete to a training load and may help in training programming or in assessing the cyclist’s training status. The development of computational models, trying to overcome the difficulties associated with setting up an experimental protocol for multifactorial analysis, is considered as a possible implementation of the multivariate analysis of the performance. A further development will embed this model in a broader multi-level biomechanical model. The final aim of the multi-level model is to include in an whole the most important variables affecting the performance in cycling and to describe the principal mutual interactions among the factors related to different levels of analysis (i.e. mechanical, muscular, physiological-bioenergetic, environmental) for a global performance assessment. A complete model will help in detailing new cyclist assessment guidelines and may have important implications for the planning and real-time monitoring of athletic performance or training loads. -
The physical, mental and hormonal responses to short-term intensified training in well-trained cyclists with a high carbohydrate nutritional intervention
Background: Short periods of intensified training (IT) are a regular feature in a cyclist’s training programme. The aim of this study was to monitor changes in performance, mood state and plasma hormones during short term IT in well-trained cyclists and the effects of a carbohydrate nutritional intervention.
Methods: Thirteen highly trained male cyclists (age: 25±6 y, V ̇O2max: 72±5 ml/kg/min) participated in two 9-day periods of intensified training while ingesting either high (HCHO) or low (LCHO) carbohydrate (CHO) beverages before (24 g vs 2 g CHO), during (60 g/h vs 20 g/h CHO) and after (44 g vs 10 g CHO) every training session. All training sessions were monitored with SRM power meters and heart rate (HR) monitors. Performance was assessed throughout IT with maximal oxygen uptake (V ̇O2max) and 1 h time trial (TT). Mood state questionnaires (POMS and DALDA) were completed daily to monitor total mood disturbance (TMD). Venous blood samples were collected before and immediately after each TT and analysed for brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), cortisol (CORT), testosterone (TEST), CORT/TEST ratio, adrenocorticotrophic hormone (ACTH) and prolactin (PRL).
Results: Weekly training volume and intensity (time spent in the three highest HR zones) increased significantly during IT (9.3±2.4 h to 23.5±3.4 h/week for volume and 2.6±2.5 to 6.5±4.0 h/week for intensity). Total energy intake and dietary CHO were significantly higher in HCHO than LCHO (4148±766 vs 3501±616 kcal/d and 679±105 vs 505±107 g/d CHO). TMD was elevated during IT (p<0.05). Overall, POMS TMD was significantly higher in LCHO than HCHO (p=0.04). Performance in the 〖V ̇O〗_2max exercise protocol fell significantly with IT in both conditions (p<0.05): peak power (391±37 to 375±38 W), maximum HR (190±10 to 179±8 bpm) and completion time (31:15±03:12 to 30:00±03:30 min:s). No significant changes in TT performance were observed over IT, or between conditions. However, absolute mean power during TT decreased non-significantly in both conditions (-1.2 W (-1%) and -7.2 W (-3%) for HCHO and LCHO, respectively). Mean HR tended to decrease from TT1-TT3 in LCHO (p=0.06). Pre-exercise CORT and BDNF tended to be lower after IT in both conditions (p=0.07) and pre-exercise ACTH tended to be lower in LCHO than HCHO (p=0.06). Post-exercise CORT, ACTH, BDNF, CORT/TEST ratio and PRL concentrations decreased with IT (p<0.05), with no difference between conditions. The post-exercise increase in PRL seen at TT1 did not occur at TT3; instead PRL concentrations fell from 373 to 348 mIU/L. Post-exercise TEST was lower in LCHO than HCHO (13.2±3.6 vs 14.6±3.8 nmol/L; p=0.03).
Discussion: A relatively short period of IT resulted in significant disturbances in mood state and minor performance decrements. LCHO resulted in significantly greater TMD than HCHO. Previous studies have reported significant declines in performance with similar exercise protocols; yet this group of well-trained athletes showed a level of resistance to the substantial increase in training load. However, hormonal changes present signs of chronic stress, including decreased post-exercise PRO, BDNF, CORT, ACTH and CORT/TEST suggesting these cyclists may have exhibited early signs of overreaching. -
Effects of different training protocols on the heart rate variability of trained cyclists
Background: Studies have shown that measures of HRV can be useful for monitoring the training load in cycling. However, most of these studies are observational and have not assessed the impact of cumulative days of training on the autonomic system.
Purpose: To evaluate the impact of three training protocols (one continuous and two interval training) performed on three consecutive days on HRV measures of trained cyclists.
Methods: 12 trained cyclists participated in this experimental study with a cross over design. Initially an incremental test was performed on a cycle ergometer. The test began with an intensity of ~50w and increased 25w/minute until exhaustion. During the test and subsequent training sessions, heart rate was measured with a Polar RS800CX. The anaerobic threshold (equivalent to the respiration compensation point) was identified from the HRV following a procedure described elsewhere (Cottin et al., 2006: International Journal of Sports Medicine, 27(12), 959-967). Three days after the incremental test, cyclists returned to the laboratory to perform – in random order - one of the three protocols: P1 - 30min at 70% of power at anaerobic threshold; P2 – six sets of 4min at 90-95% of power at anaerobic threshold separated by 1min at 50w and P3 – eight sets of 1min at 120% of power at anaerobic threshold with 3min of recovery at 50w. All protocols were performed consecutively on three days and there was a four-day washout period between protocols. During 30minutes after the training sessions, participants remained seated for measuring HRV. The averages of minute 10 to 20 (post 15) and 20 to 30 (post 25) were analyzed. The parameters of HRV studied were mean of RR intervals (Mean RR), standard deviation of Mean RR (SDNN), square root of SDNN2 (RMSSD), low frequency (LF; 0 – 0.15 Hz) and high frequency (HF; >0.15 – 0.40 Hz) and its ratio (LF/HF) and the total power (TP). Rating of perceived effort (RPE) was obtained 30minutes after each training session. The training impulse (TRIMP) for each training session was also calculated following the Bannister approach.
Results: Cyclists had a mean age of 28±7 years and 72.6±9.1kg of body weight. The mean peak power output and power at anaerobic threshold were 333.2±37.7 and 267.4±37.0 watts, respectively. In general, there were no differences across the days regardless the HRV indices evaluated. However, Mean RR, RMSSD and LF/HF were lower for P2 compared to the other two protocols at post 15 and post 25. Accordingly, RPE was higher for P2 compared to the other protocols. The TRIMP was similar between P1 and P2 and both were higher than P3 (p<0.001). None of the HRV parameters showed differences at the moment prior the training sessions.
Discussion: The main findings of the present study are that: a) the training sessions proposed did not show any cumulative effect over the days on the HRV parameters of trained cyclists and b) P2 had a higher impact on HRV indices than the other protocols. The later finding is in accordance with a higher RPE for P2.
Conclusion: These results support the notion that not only the intensity but also other parameters such as duration of effort and recovery impact on the internal load and thus must be taken into consideration when prescribing training in order to maximize performance and avoid overtraining. Intensities around the anaerobic threshold might have a greater impact on the HRV than intensities above or below it.
-
Incorporating internal mechanical power into performance models in cycling
Background: A number of models have been developed to establish the energy cost of cycling. These models have become better refined to account for the various energy demands, including air and rolling resistances. Among the established models, however, there does not appear to be sufficient consideration for changes to internal mechanical power (IP), the rate of energy to move the limbs against gravitational and inertial forces. Values up to 100 W have been reported for IP in cycling for cadences between 80 and 115 , and so the inclusion of IP in performance prediction models is arguably warranted. Quantifying IP has previously been done using either 1) a physiological approach (IPmet), in which the metabolic counterpart of the external mechanical power (power applied to the cranks) was subtracted from Ė (energy expenditure) to equal the metabolic equivalent of IPmet, which was then multiplied by delta efficiency (DE) to yield the IPmet; or 2) a biomechanical approach (IPmech), which used an inverse dynamics analysis of the kinematics and kinetics of cycling. Both approaches have notable advantages and limitations, which is why quantifying a range for IP, delimited by IPmet and IPmech, has been proposed by this research group.
Purpose: The aim of this study was to assess whether incorporating a range of values for IP into an established performance model would provide a better prediction of Ė than when IP was not included.
Methods: Steady-state Ė was measured (K4 b2, Cosmed, Rome, Italy) for 10 elite male cyclists who cycled for 5-6 min at 200 W at 80 and 110 on the flat duckboard of an outdoor velodrome in calm conditions. Steady-state Ė was compared to Ė predicted by the established model (Equation 1, see in PDF document) (di Prampero et al. 1979: Journal of Applied Physiology, 47(1), 201-106; Olds et al. Journal of Applied Physiology, 75(2), 730-737):
and Ė predicted by the model that includes IP (IPmet and IPmech) (Equation 2, see in PDF document):
where the first term of both equations represents the cost due to air resistance and includes a coefficient of drag (Cdrag), the projected frontal surface area (Afrontal), the air density (r), the velocity of the wind (vw) and the steady-state velocity of the cyclist (vss). The second term represents the cost due to rolling resistance, where Crr is the coefficient of rolling resistance, S is the angle of terrain, mbody and mbicycle are the masses of the participant’s body and bicycle, respectively. IPmet and IPmech were determined in the laboratory for each cyclist in an identical cycling position to that adopted in the outdoor trials.
Results: Mean (± s) measured at 80 was 866 W (± 78 W) and at 110 was 937 W (± 75 W). The mean difference (± 95% limits of agreement) between measured and predicted by Equation 1 was -98 W (± 214 W) at 80 and -185 W (± 191 W) at 110 . When IPmet was included in the prediction (Equation 2), mean differences (± 95% limits of agreement) were 125 W (± 192 W) and 182 W (± 153 W) at 80 and 110 , respectively. The mean differences (± 95% limits of agreement) between measured and predicted by Equation 2 incorporating IPmech were -48 W (± 201 W) at 80 and -148 W (± 274 W) at 110 .
Discussion: Energy expenditure () predicted using an already-established model was shown, in this study, to fall short of the measured from respiratory gas during outdoor cycling for most participants at 80 and for all at 110 . Inclusion of IPmech into the performance prediction model resulted in values closer to the measured , however they were not sufficiently large enough to account for the entire deficit from the original prediction model (Equation 1) at either cadence. When the upper limit of the IP range, IPmet, was incorporated it more than compensated, in almost all cases, for the deficit from Equation 1. That is to say, the measured during outdoor cycling fell within the range of values that was predicted for when estimates of IP were considered in the model.
Conclusion: Based on these results, it is recommended that future predictions of cycling performance include a cost for IP.
-
Does six-weeks of high-intensity cycle training with induced changes in acid-base balance lead to mitochondrial adaptations?
Background: Endurance training leads to an improved ability of muscle to utilize oxygen. This is related to an increased density and function of mitochondria. The biogenesis and adaptation of mitochondria is a complex process mediated by various signalling pathways and seems to be highly sensitive to the type of exercise and the local environment in the muscle. Changes in the muscle environment in terms of altered metabolism and substrate accumulation are affected by changes in acid/base balance in response to exercise. Recent studies (Bishop et al., 2010:Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab, 299:E225-233; Edge et al., 2006: J Appl Physiol, 101:918-925) have shown that changes in acid/base balance may affect the regulation of mitochondrial adaptation to acute exercise; however, how these changes are affected by training and relate to performance adaptations in humans is unclear. Similarly, the effect of acid/base balance on mechanisms underlying mitochondrial biogenesis is unclear.
Purpose: The objectives of this study were to examine the relationship between acid/base balance, mitochondrial biogenesis and adaptation.
Methods: Nineteen recreationally active men undertook six-weeks (3 x wk) high-intensity interval training programme, known to produce increases in mitochondrial biogenesis. Training sessions involved repeated 2-min efforts at an intensity ranging from 85-110% VO2peak separated by 1 min recoveries. Participants were matched for maximum oxygen consumption and randomly assigned to one of two different training groups. One group ingested sodium bicarbonate (alkaline, 0.4 g.kg-1 body weight) and the other ingested a placebo prior to each training session. Performance test results, blood samples and muscle biopsies were collected before and after the training period and assessed for changes in aerobic fitness, blood metabolites and markers of mitochondrial function and biogenesis. Changes in gene expression associated with mitochondrial biogenesis were also examined.
Results: Post training, there were significant (P < 0.05) improvements in time to fatigue (mean ± SD) for placebo (54.9 ± 26.6%) and alkaline (74.7 ± 40.0%) groups, significant increases in maximum power output (8.8 ± 5.% vs 10.6 ± 6.5%) and lactate threshold power (5.7 ± 7.0% vs 9.4 ± 10.1%) were also seen in both groups. There were also significant increases in citrate synthase activity in the alkaline group (22.3 ± 26.7&) and VO2peak in the placebo group (9.2 ± 5.6%). Trends for improvements were also seen in citrate synthase activity in the placebo group (12.6 ± 19.3%) and VO2peak in the alkaline group (4.5 ± 6.9%), however these did not reach significance (P = 0.089 and 0.066 respectively). Despite the significant changes in performance within a group, there were no significant differences between groups.
Discussion: Both training groups showed substantial changes in performance and physiological measures following the training period, however, suppressing exercise-induced acidosis during training did not significantly improve mitochondrial adaptations or performance in comparison to a placebo condition. There was a large degree of individual variation in the responses of physiological and performance measures to the treatments, however there were trends towards greater local metabolic and muscular adaptations when exercise-induced acidosis was reduced.
Conclusion: The relationship between acid/base balance and mitochondrial adaptations in humans is complex. Individual differences in training responses at a local muscular and central level in this study highlight the need to gain a better understanding of how alterations in exercise-induced acidosis affect specific cellular events leading to skeletal muscle adaptation. -
Comparison of physiological and perceptual responses to a maximal exhaustive test performed on the SRM and the Cyclus2 ergometer
Background: No cycle ergometer perfectly replicates the physiological demands and movement patterns associated with real world cycling (Abbiss et al., 2009: International Journal of Sports Medicine, 30(2), 107-112). The purpose of this research was to compare physiological and perceptual responses during a standardized exercise test using the classical SRM ergometer (Schoberer Rad Messtechnik, GmbH, Jülich, Germany) and the Cyclus2 ergometer (RBM elektronik-automation GmbH, Leipzig, Germany) which allows the use of personal bikes and allows lateral movement.
Methods: 13 moderately trained cyclists (mean ± SD: age 35 ± 7 years, body mass 74.1 ± 9.6 kg) performed two graded cycling tests to volitional exhaustion in a randomized order on the SRM and the Cyclus2 ergometer. Maximal aerobic capacity (VO2max), maximal aerobic power (MAP), blood lactate concentrations and heart rate responses were compared using a paired t-test. Participants were also required to fill in the NASA Task Load Index (TLX) questionnaire (Hart, 2006: NASA-Task Load Index, 50th Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Meeting, Santa Monica, USA) after each test to assess the perceived workload in an effort to understand if one ergometer is perceived to be more or less of a workload than its counterpart. In order to analyse the workload from each participant, individual TXL factors were summed for each ergometer TLX administration creating an overall workload score per ergometer. After conclusion of the experiment participants were asked to state their preference in ergometers. Lastly, a correlation was performed on the level of performance within the ergometer testing and the perceived performance.
Results: Compared physiological responses and MAP (321 ± 44 W; SRM and 326 ± 41 W; Cyclus2) did not find any significant differences. A constructed ANOVA model which examined the difference of the overall workload scores between the two ergometers did not show any significant difference (F(1,12) = .025, p = .876). In order to examine if there were individual factor differences between the six TLX factors of each ergometer, a constructed repeated measure MANOVA did not reveal any significant differences between ergometers and within individual TLX scores (F(5,8) = .995, p = .477). Interestingly, the absolute VO2max performance score was significantly correlated on the Cyclus2 ergometer with the self-reported performance TLX factor (r = .560, p = .047) while the same score was not significant for the SRM ergometer (r = .247, p = .415). However, participants were highly positively correlated between perceived performance on each ergometer (r = .736, p = .004). Participants were asked to name which ergometer they felt they performed better on. Eight participants named the SRM Ergometer, while 5 named the Cyclus2. When asked which ergometer they preferred to use, 4 named the SRM Ergometer, while 9 named the Cyclus2. When asked which ergometer the participant would prefer to use if the test were to be run again, 5 named the SRM Ergometer, while 8 named the Cyclus2. Participants were lastly asked to think of how comfortable they were for each of the ergometers. A paired t-test examined the differences between the comfort ratings of revealed a significant difference (t = -2.803, p = .016), with this being driven by the higher favourable ratings of the Cyclus2 compared to the SRM (Figure 1). These differences can be accounted for by 6 participants stating that they preferred the Cyclus2 and increased comfort owning to the usage of their own bike. Those that preferred the SRM stated it was more solid and stable (n = 4).
Discussion: Biomechanical factors can influence physiological responses, perception of exercise and efficiency of an individual riding a bicycle or ergometer at a given power output (Patterson and Moreno, 1990: Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 22(4), 512-516. Whilst not demonstrating any differences in physiological variables and MAP, participants generally felt more comfortable on the ergometer, which allows the use of personal bikes and which appears to replicate real world cycling more closely. -
Treadmill-based cycling time trial better predicts seasonal cross-country mountain bike performance than traditional parameters in laboratory tests
Specific cross-country mountain bike (MTB) laboratory tests are used to monitor training and performance of elite athletes. To better follow up long-term performance development we designed a new MTB specific treadmill-based cycling time trial. The purpose of this study was to investigate the relationship between different physiological parameters from this new test as well as from traditional laboratory tests and overall MTB performance in the following season.
Thirteen male cyclists (24.1 ± 3.6 y; 175.9 ± 5.1 cm; 68.1 ± 4.0 kg; 606 ± 589 UCI points) of the Swiss National MTB Team completed three laboratory tests to exhaustion within two days. On the first day, the athletes performed two tests on an SRM cycle ergometer: 1) a long graded exercise test (LGXT) (workload increased 30 W/5 min) to determine the lactate threshold (LT1), the Dmod threshold (Bishop et al., 1998: Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 30(8), 1270–1275), and peak power output (PPOLGXT); and 2) a short graded exercise test (SGXT) (workload increased 25 W/min) to determine maximal oxygen uptake (V̇O2max) and peak power output (PPOSGXT). On the second day, the athletes performed a MTB-specific 24-min time trial (TT) with variable inclination (4 - 10°) on a motorized treadmill (3x4.5 m) using their own bikes. The athletes were instructed to ride at a self-selected maximal pace and the total distance covered in 24 min was used as the performance measure. All performance-based parameters are expressed relative to body mass. The season performance was evaluated using the International Cycling Union (UCI) points. Pearson correlation analysis was applied to determine the relationship between physiological parameters and the UCI points.
The UCI points correlated significantly with TT distance, PPOLGXT and Dmod (r = 0.83, p = 0.001; r = 0.76, p = 0.003 and r = 0.67, p = 0.012). No significant correlation was observed between V̇O2max, PPOSGXT and LT1 and the UCI points (r = 0.41, p = 0.144; r = 0.49, p = 0.077 and r = 0.51, p = 0.077).
The current test battery indicates that TT distance is the best correlate of seasonal MTB performance, with TT distance explaining 68% of the observed variance in UCI points. Furthermore, high UCI rankings were also highly correlated with PPOLGXT and the related Dmod during the LGXT. In contrast V̇O2max, traditionally regarded as an important determinant of endurance performance (Coyle et al., 1988: Journal of Applied Physiology, 64, 2622–2630), and PPOSGXT, did not show a significant correlation with UCI points in this group of athletes. In accordance with these findings, we observed that younger athletes often achieved comparable values as elite athletes in the SGXT, suggesting the performance difference (UCI points) is differentiated only by the distance completed in the treadmill-based cycling TT. It appears that graded exercise tests of a short duration do not adequately represent the duration that a given workload can be sustained.
Therefore for a comprehensive MTB-specific laboratory test battery, we suggest including a MTB-specific time trial with a constant test duration to predict seasonal MTB performance.
